Concern Level: High
This series follows an approach to slipping in content that should be very familiar to Christian parents at this point. This particular scheme waits ... → Continue reading below
Upside-Down Magic
VERDICT: Avoid
Concern Level: High

Concern LevelHigh
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
This series follows an approach to slipping in content that should be very familiar to Christian parents at this point. This particular scheme waits until a series gets very popular and, much later, slowly, but surely slips things in. While we have not completed a thorough review of the entire series, we have read and verified the following content below after being warned by a concerned parent. In “Weather or Not” (book 5 of the series), a good portion of the plot revolves around the story of a hero from the past who heroically saved the town. However, quite a bit later in the story we are told the related story of her female “partner”. When the young child being told the story says, “partner?” the adult replies, “yes, her life companion”. Later we are told how both “settled down” together in the town. Also, strangely in this book, we noticed a group of students have a presentation topic of “single-sex education”. In “The Big Shrink” (book 6) we meet a kid named Rainey at a party. They are described as a “tall non-binary boy”. As we have seen in previous books that attempted to desensitize kids to this unbiblical view of gender, the rest of the references consist of super-confusing references and grammar, such as referring to this child in the singular using words that make no sense like “they sank into a chair” and when Rainey “opened up their hands”. We also noticed that this story uses the term “fart” and “farting” over and over. The kids also launch into a huge protest against the leadership of the school when the toys that the students have become obsessed over are banned during school hours. In “Night Owl” (book 8) we all of a sudden find out that Sebastian has “two dads”. Early there is a comment that “his dads were great”. One he refers to as “dad” and the other he refers to as “Baba”. This feels a lot like how network TV and then later Disney tried to slowly desensitize adults and then children to this type of non-biblical views of love/marriage and gender. It really makes us brokenhearted thinking about the very young readers of this series. We don’t think there is much else to say (see our thoughts in the next section), but for completeness we will share potentially concerning content specific to this first title: The main item to consider will be around magic. Here the magic is “lighter” and doesn’t revolve around fighting/violence like in other series, but it is obviously a core focus of the series. At one point Rory’s “upside-down” powers cause a huge mess and destruction to her father’s office. Her older brother says they should lie and blame it on their other sister’s rabbits. She asks about being honest, but he tells her they don’t want father mad at her before a big upcoming test. She concludes, “Some lies are safer than the truth”, a terrible takeaway for kids. This is followed by a few other similar acts of deception (brother and sister completely disregarding their father’s order to not call Rory, Rory lying to get out of tricky situations). A couple other items: We hear of a male nurse who wears unicorn scrubs. A girl mentions that her grandparent let her watch as much TV as she wants, calling it a good thing.
VerdictAvoid
Our Thoughts
Reviewing books can certainly be tricky. We were all setup to post this book as one that really just depends on your family's policy around “magic”. We planned to say that if you were comfortable with a story revolving around lighter “magical” abilities with kids (things like turning into animals and such) then this is a lighthearted book with only a handful of items to consider. We also saw nothing in any other reviews that we checked out after preparing our perspective. Fortunately, God recently had a parent reach out to us voicing concern around this series. While they did not provide any context, it was enough as God used it to lead us to dig further (we are so incredibly thankful to God for this!). Now, we realize that especially with these being “lighter” side character type references, some Christians may choose to let their children read this, using it as a chance to discuss these topics. Others may choose to just avoid these later books. But our perspective is that if we as Christians don’t send a message to authors and other content creators that we are not ok with this then we are partially to blame. This is especially true given the young audience that this book will draw in (consider the ‘cute’ drawings on the covers). We saw this with Disney recently, where it took a whole lot of us not paying to see a string of agenda-driven movies before the company took a strong change in course. God asks us to stand up, even if the world thinks we are crazy. Because of this, we consider this like the rest of our “series that went off the rails” and believe this is one to Avoid.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
In a world of elite magic academies, weird and wonderful things happen when you're sent off to public school . . . and put in the Upside-Down Magic class. It's never easy when your magic goes wonky. For Nory, this means that instead of being able to turn into a dragon or a kitten, she turns into both of them at the same time-a dritten. For Elliott, the simple act of conjuring fire from his fingertips turns into a fully frozen failure. For Andres, wonky magic means he's always floating in the air, bouncing off the walls, or sitting on the ceiling. For Bax, a bad moment of magic will turn him into a . . . actually, he'd rather not talk about that. Nory, Elliott, Andres, and Bax are just four of the students in Dunwiddle Magic School's Upside-Down Magic class. In their classroom, lessons are unconventional, students are unpredictable, and magic has a tendency to turn wonky at the worst possible moments. Because it's always amazing, the trouble a little wonky magic can cause . . .
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books
This is something that we pray God will never let happen on this site, posting a positive review for a series that later goes off the rails.
Read ReviewBlessed is the one who does not walk in step with the wicked or stand in the way that sinners take or sit in the company of mockers, but whose delight is in the law of the Lord, and who meditates on his law day and night. That person is like a tree planted by streams of water, which yields its fruit in season and whose leaf does not wither—whatever they do prospers.
— Psalm 1:1-3
More Christian Parent Reviews