Treasure in the Lake

VERDICT: Recommended

Concern Level: Low

Book Cover for Treasure in the Lake

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

There is not much to list here for potentially concerning content in this short graphic novel. The main thing to be aware of is that Iris, one of the two main characters, shows some unfortunate behavior a couple of times, especially at the start of the story. She gets angry at her mom on a call, eventually slamming the phone and hanging up on her. She then chooses to leave the house without permission at night while mom is away. When her friend Sam asks her about potentially moving away, saying “what about our parents?” she responds, “What about them?”. A couple of times she is rude and self-centered, occasionally even justifying her behavior. We never felt this was shown as clearly wrong to the young reader. The young lady Iris meets a character that the story seems to indicate has passed away a long time ago. She appears in the story normal, but the author appears to be indicating Iris is seeing into the past. These friends sneak out at night, “borrow” tools from other people’s yards and go out to a remote area (cast in a pretty positive light). Luck is mentioned. “What the…” is uttered. When asked why a child is breaking a clear rule the response comes back, “because she can”.

Our Thoughts

This short work has beautiful illustrations and is mostly clean. The children that the story focuses on, especially the young lady Iris, leave something to be desired from a likability standpoint, but later an older man comes along and is very nice to the kids. While not ideal, this is an ok option to consider if your child enjoys reading graphic novels as there are few and far between clean options out there.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

Grand adventures stories often begin where you least expect them… Iris knows this because she’s read them all. However, as a thirteen-year-old stuck in the tiny town of Bugden, real adventure seems like a distant dream. But when Iris and her best friend, Sam, stumble upon an unusually dry river on the outskirts of town, they’re led to a discovery beyond anything Iris has ever read about: a hidden city and a forgotten tale of friendship. In Jason Pamment's middle grade graphic novel debut, perfect for fans of Hilda and This Was Our Pact, can Iris and Sam uncover the truth in time to keep their own friendship afloat, or will history repeat itself and pull them apart forever? An ALSC Graphic Novel Reading List Title

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Better Reading
Our Thoughts on this Review

Solid review worth reading through.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

But test them all; hold on to what is good, reject every kind of evil. May God himself, the God of peace, sanctify you through and through. May your whole spirit, soul and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.

— 1 Thessalonians 5:21-23

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews

Christian Review of The Hero's Guide to Saving Your Kingdom
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Invisible: A Graphic Novel
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of The Secret at Pheasant Cottage
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of Ali Cross
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Hilo: The boy who crashed to Earth
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Terra: An Elemental Series
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of The Unteachables
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Slugfest
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Honestly Elliott
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Fairest of All - Whatever After 1
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of The Hidden Hand
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of History Comics: Ellis Island
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Percy Jackson and the Olympians - The Lightning Thief
Concern Level: High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of The Prince and the Dressmaker
Concern Level: High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of Timmy Failure - Mistakes were Made
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Avoid