See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

The Winter King

VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for The Winter King

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

There are a few aspects of this book that may surprise some parents. The Winter King is described as the town’s ‘god’. This is continued through much of the story. There are times when we hear prayer, but then realize it is to this “Winter King”. There are creatures who lurk in the woods of the village. They are described as “the undead”. They won’t enter town, but will snatch villagers who wander too close to the tree-line. A comment is made that if a body was ever found it was hardly recognizable. Note that there is very little of this “horror-like” content in the book outside of this, making it seemingly out of place. There is other intense content that may steer some parents away. Several past events are described. In one three boys died in a world attack. In another a wicked man is said to have beat a maid who missed work. There is a key flashback to a man ice fishing and falling in through the ice and drowning. She sees a wolf and worries it may “rip her throat open”. Cora is beaten with a belt by an evil man (gives some detail) and later pinned to the wall and choked by a wicked boy. At one point a good wolf grabs a villain by the throat and drags him away with a large trail of blood. There is some pseudo-spiritual content from the village. Green tassels are sold to ward off evil spirits. At another point they wish they could summon a spirit to sprinkle a sleep spell. In another instance we hear of someone hoping “to all the gods”. At one point she sees her dad and later her brother who have passed away in ‘spirit’ form (meant to be good, not dark). The main character Cora lies quite often to get out of dangerous or tricky situations. It should also be noted that the book, told through her eyes, is very bleak for the vast majority of the story. Mature readers will realize she has been put in an impossible situation and that is what has driven her to bitterness and negativity, but for others this may make this title not be the right choice. This presents itself in many ways (e.g., calling a girl she knows “a wretch of a daughter”, thinking other very unkind thoughts and justifying negative actions). At one point when a girl who is very unkind to her has her mother die Cora thinks, “now she knows how it feels”). At one point when things get really dark Cora start to believe that there is “no on out there” (implying no God, this is later changed a bit, but dark thoughts at the moment for a kids book). Other items to be aware of: The yearly elk sacrifice is described in a decent amount of detail, including blood spilling and flowing down the temple steps. Luck is mentioned several times.

Our Thoughts

One interesting aspect of this book from a Christian perspective is the feeling right away, at least to us, that this was going to be a powerful Christian allegory. All of the aspects seemed to be there. We even flipped to the author’s bio early on to see if we had a hint of what was driving this story. The strongest suggestion towards this comes when Cora, the main character, sees a book about the god-like character with a drawing titled “the King who died”. She feels the book pulling on her. But… like our experience with the bio, what we thought might come never did. This is just a story, which is of course fine, but we want to help spare others reading expectantly to find a message and lesson that just isn’t there. Even more importantly we need to make sure that our children aren’t searching for truths in a source where they are not to be found here (or worse, pulling out false or half-truths because they assumed real biblical Truth was present). There are some positive aspects of this book and you can see why many people, including many Christians have sung its praises. It is a deep and captivating tale. For one, we see just how much impact we can have on others. There are Christian organizations around the world rescuing people from the type of real-world situations that Cora and her family found herself in. That is a huge thing to talk with your children about! This book can help readers who are ready truly understand the impact of real poverty. A few really kind characters remind us of who we are supposed to be as Christians in the lives of others, especially those in the greatest need (even though there are no Christian characters in the book). Friendship is one thing that is placed in a very positive light, as nearly everyone has turned their back on the main family from this story to protect themselves, but Peter and his family have refused to. Peter’s mother watches the young children at no cost for them. They give gifts and provide much needed connection, sustaining them. A positive light is shown on the value of hard work and the power of reading. This is a solid story and there is quite a bit of good here… but Christian parents really need to take the previous section seriously and determine if their readers are ready. Because of this we are making this one a Prayerfully Consider.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

A village trapped in winter, a tyrannical god, and a girl who will do anything to keep her family alive... FINALIST FOR THE 2020 CHRISTY AWARD in the Young Adult category Ever since Cora's father disappeared through the ice, whispers about her family's "curse" have grown increasingly louder. Desperate to help her mother and siblings survive another bleak season in the Winter King's frozen grasp, Cora begins to bend (and even break) the rules she has kept since she was a little girl. But when she discovers a secret that's much bigger than herself, she realizes too late that she has put herself-and those she loves-in even greater peril. Wintry and dangerous but hauntingly lovely, The Winter King is the debut novel from author Christine Cohen. Canonball Books is the children's imprint of Canon Press. At Canonball, we believe stories are soul food, so you can expect excitement, danger, loyalty, virtue, and family in your Canonball books. Feed your kids the right books!

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Christian Review
Redeemed Reader
Our Thoughts on this Review

Interesting note pointing to parallels with a C.S. Lewis title and several great discussion points.

Warnings

While the review does mention a bit about Cora’s mindset and circumstances, overall there is little warning about the potentially concerning content.

Read Review
Secular Review (use with Caution!)
The Story Warren
Warnings

Sadly, no concerning content is mentioned.

Read Review
Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Realm of Books
Our Thoughts on this Review

We appreciate the concerning content rating up front that gives parents an initial indication there is material they need to be aware of with a section providing some details.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

All a person's ways seem pure to them, but motives are weighed by the Lord. Commit to the Lord whatever you do, and he will establish your plans. The Lord works out everything to its proper end—even the wicked for a day of disaster.

— Proverbs 16:2-3

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews