Concern Level: Medium
The source of much of the concerning content is the only son in the family, Oliver. He is pretty awful the whole book. When speaking about the incre... → Continue reading below
The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street
VERDICT: Recommended
(with caution)
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
The source of much of the concerning content is the only son in the family, Oliver. He is pretty awful the whole book. When speaking about the incredibly unkind landlord much of the plot revolves around, Oliver remarks, “What a punk”. We see a few other remarks like this, such as “rotten”, “what a waste”, jerk face. When trying to figure out how to get the landlord to not evict them, Oliver suggests they “spray paint his door with disgusting bathroom words”. He says his sister’s singing is very bad (this type of thing happens quite often). A fort has orange Fanta, which “Oliver had to hide from his mother”. He sneaks to find where his mom has hidden the cookies and later he grabs the last cookie quickly so no one else can have it. He tells a sister, “Why don’t you tell me what you want me to say so I can say it and go on with my life?” Similarly, his friends add fake names to enlarge a petition. When mom tells him to be home in an hour he replies, “yeah, yeah”. When he knows his mother needs help with something important, he sneaks in and hides in his room. When she calls him, he puts on headphones and hopes that she is too tired to come get him. Oliver pretends to gag over his sister’s cooking. We would highly recommend you talk to your kids about this particular child’s character and not emulate it. We see some similar behavior from other siblings. Oliver’s sister Jessie “got distracted pretending the gumdrops were (the landlord’s) eyes and she was stabbing them with the toothpick”. Isa and Jessie lie to mom to hide their efforts to save their home. The kids deceive a nice man, saying it was for a good reason (later shown to be remorseful). The twins have a “place to stash halloween candy before mama confiscates it”. Near the culmination, Isa tells the landlord, “You are a terrible, grouchy, horrible person. You are mean”. When two sisters are making up, the one who was wronged and upset makes the other sister promise more and more favors like covering chores before she forgives her and moves on (sadly this is meant to be a sweet scene, but sets a bad example). With all of this unfortunate children behavior, and besides seemingly engaged parents, there is very little adult correction. On a bit of a heavier note, a newspaper clipping tells the story of a mom and daughter who died when struck by a cab while crossing the road. This comes up a few times and is obviously a bit heavy and sad. Other items to be aware of: Jessie remarks “We’ve been so good, there might as well be halos over our heads!” Similarly, a set of neighbors are “perfect in every way”. A sister is called “perfect Isa”. She also yells “fudge” repeatedly when something goes wrong. It is even referred to as an "expletive" The term “miracle” is used flippantly a few times. A neighbor smokes a cigarette. A character says, “Your brownstone is the only reason I don’t run away and find new parents” When it is revealed, the mean landlord lost his wife and child, Oliver speculates that maybe he killed them. We hear a passing reference to werewolf and ghost. A sister says she believes there are monsters at night and no one corrects her. The following terms are used: freaking, sucks, that blows, dummy
VerdictRecommended
Our Thoughts
This book opens with two quotes focused on seeing the value in something we often take for granted, the place we call home (“Home and I are such good friends”). This cord runs through the whole book. We see a close-knit family who finds out that their recluse and grumpy landlord will soon make them move away. This book is well written and engaging. The mother and father are loving towards the children and those in their neighbors. For those of you who are familiar with one of our series we have ever recommended, this reminds us of a secular version of The Baxter Family Children books. It has a lot of the same aspects, but the absence of the faith aspect of course keeps it far from what it could have been. Speaking of our faith, at one point in this journey, when the news gets out that this family has to move away, we see a set of older neighbors actually cry because they are so upset to think about them leaving. Similarly, other neighbors show deep remorse. This got us thinking. In our modern-day individualistic culture, what would be the response of our neighbors if we, as a Christian family, moved from our current neighborhood / apartment building / etc.? What type of impact are we having on those who God has placed closest to us (geographically)? What could we do differently to have more of an impact for Christ? Another potential discussion point for the Christian family is the fact that hurting people, hurt people. As the story unfolds we see this play out very clearly. It is good for us to talk with our children about this, explaining that often people are batting things we don’t get to see. The ending of this one is stunningly sweet and heartwarming. For those who feel comfortable with the concerning content for their particular reader, this is one we Recommend. Enjoy.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
The first book in the bestselling series that the New York Times Book Review hails as “delightful and heartwarming.” The Vanderbeekers have always lived in the brownstone on 141st Street. It's practically another member of the family. So when their reclusive, curmudgeonly landlord decides not to renew their lease, the five siblings have eleven days to do whatever it takes to stay in their beloved home and convince the dreaded Beiderman just how wonderful they are. And all is fair in love and war when it comes to keeping their home. The New York Times bestselling Vanderbeekers series is perfect for fans of the Penderwicks. As Booklist commented in a starred review: “Few families in children’s literature are as engaging or amusing as the Vanderbeekers, even in times of turmoil.”
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
This one highlights an issue we often see with this review source. For some reason, despite its Christian core, this site often puts very little focus on concerning content. Even the “review” aspect of this setup is very light. Disappointing.
Read ReviewWe really like aspects of this review. A lot of good content here.
As is typical of this site, there is not much focus on concerning content.
Read ReviewSimilar here for this Catholic site. Very little focus on content parents would find concerning.
As is typical of this site, there is not much focus on concerning content.
Read ReviewTherefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles. And let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us, fixing our eyes on Jesus, the pioneer and perfecter of faith. For the joy set before him he endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God.
— Hebrews 12:1-2
More Christian Parent Reviews