See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

The Trouble with Heroes

VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for The Trouble with Heroes

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

This book is one of growth and healing, but parents should know that the character we see this book through the eyes of (Finn) is a very hurting young man and his behavior and inner-dialogue along this path is something you will need to consider for your particular reader. We highly encourage parents to read through all of this section, but also the next to get the full picture for their decision on this one.

Tragedy Finn’s his life has made him very negative and sinical, and at times immoral. We will share details here so you can properly weigh this and determine if your reader can/should wade through this on the path to healing:

  • The book opens around vandalism that Finn has committed, but the most concerning part is that at this point in his journey he shows no remorse and says, “Next time I do this I’ll be smarter”. (He remarks that a part of what he did was to “let God know how mad you are”.
  • He refers to an assignment as an “Introductory Poem for the Stupid Poetry Class”. Another title refers to the assignment as “pointless”
  • “There’s no such thing as a hero… Name your hero and give me an hour online. I’ll do a deep-dive search and pull up everything you didn’t want to know. Who they cheated and cheated on…”
  • During this down time, we hear a lot about him skipping classes and work.
  • We see mom really trying with Finn, to which he says or thinks things like “whatever”, “fine”, “blah blah blah”.
  • One of the best parts of the story revolves around mentors that come alongside Finn, but early on much of his inner dialogue is very critical of these people. He also tries and manipulates one of these ladies early on, only being nice to her when he realizes he needs something.
  • While studying an ant carrying something, all of a sudden he just flocks it, mocking it as he does.
  • Finn shares what people wrote in his yearbook last year, but then adds a sinical “what they really meant” after it. For example, “Thanks for being a good friend” is shown to really mean “Thanks for letting me copy your math”. At one point he thinks, “SHUT UP YOU STUPID COW NANNY!”. He thinks to himself that one is “blabbering on”.
  • He lies to one mentor and justifies it to himself

There is a lot of this as it comes page after page for much of the book.

There is also a heaviness parents should be aware of. Finn has lost his farther, but the circumstances bring some extra weight/heaviness. The backstory involves Finn’s father as a rescuer during 9/11 that never fully came back from the experience. We eventually find out he fell into drinking and eventually completely retreats by pouring his full life and attention into his work as a paramedic, which more heaviness is introduced as this is shown during very tragic times during Covid. Mom eventually left Dad with Finn. Finn is carrying all this around with him and no faith/hope to lean on (at one point the book has Finn think “Now that Dad’s gone, I don’t think we believe anymore” in reference to the chance of a miracle). To add to this, it all leads Finn to wrestle with whether the absence of his father meant he didn’t really love him or his mother.

Other items to be aware of:

A comment is made, “Did you know there are horror movie monsters in these woods?”. Similarly, someone comments “There are ghosts on the trail today”.

There is a point near the end where Finn seems to imply his dad and other deceased are “drifting through this wide-open wild”. Later Finn comments of a deceased lady, “since you’re looking down from wherever now”.

There is a local superstition that if you take a rock from a particular mountain it won’t rain. Both Finn and his guide do it.

A local story is told of someone who accidently shot himself. Story mentions “bleeding all over”.

A friend says, “Dude, you look like you got in a bar fight”.

The following terms appear: farty-butted, crotch, crap, farts, stupid-butt, screwed, omg, nerd, jerk, stupid. There are flippant uses of “oh my god”, “for God’s sake”, “what in God’s name”. A character is said to have cussed loudly and at one point when attacked by hornets Finn “swears like a sailor”. A mountain is named “Nipple Top”

Our Thoughts

This is a story of healing after an unthinkably hard experience (here without faith involved). But like many of the more meaningful stories that fall into this category, the journey to get there can be a hard one to get through and won’t be for every young reader (as cataloged above).

As far as what we liked… The ending really is very sweet and we see such a change. Along the way we really neat and diverse unexpected set of characters come along that come to mentor and (literally) walk alongside Finn. Even the way the person wronged by Finn’s vandalism chooses to handle it, offering up grace and a path to reconciliation is really neat. All in a neat delivery with a neat positive emphasis on hiking, the outdoors and baking (with some really neat recipes added in). Is the journey worth it for your reader(s)? Honestly, that is one we feel you will need to Prayerfully Consider.

Plot Summary

Note: This information is typically from the publisher.

Use with caution

Bestselling and award-winning author Kate Messner takes readers on a heart-filling journey as a boy finds his path to healing.

One summer.

46 mountain peaks.

A second chance to make things right.

Finn Connelly is nothing like his dad, a star athlete and firefighter hero who always ran toward danger until he died two years ago. Finn's about to fail seventh grade and has never made headlines . . . until now.

Caught on camera vandalizing a cemetery, he's in big trouble for kicking down some dead old lady's headstone. But it turns out that grave belongs to a legendary local mountain climber, and her daughter makes Finn an unusual offer...climb all forty-six Adirondack High Peaks with her dead mother's dog, and they can call it even.

In a wild three months of misadventures, mountain mud, and unexpected mentors, Finn begins to find his way on the trails. At the top of each peak, he can see for miles and slowly begins to understand more about himself and his dad. But the mountains don't care about any of that, and as the clock ticks down to September, they have more surprises in store. Finn's final summit challenge may be more than even a hero can face.

Purchase Link

Above Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.

Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Christian Review
Redeemed Reader
Warnings

Almost zero focus on potentially concerning content from this Christian review source. This is often a concern with this site, but this one has almost nothing in the “Consideration” section. Very disappointing.

Read Review
Christian Review
Plugged In
Our Thoughts on this Review

We always like the Discussion Topics from this source. We like the “Parents of younger readers…” note (although we do feel it is really easy to miss in the “Additional Comments” pages down).

Warnings

A bit more focus on potentially concerning content than the previous Christian-source review, but we still find this so hard to get a real feel for “should my child read this” from this setup and approach.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

For the grace of God has appeared that offers salvation to all people. It teaches us to say 'No' to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, while we wait for the blessed hope—the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.

— Titus 2:11-14