See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

The Sherlock Society

VERDICT: Recommended
 (with caution)

Concern Level: Medium-Low

Book Cover for The Sherlock Society

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

This book is relatively light on concerning content. Most of what we do see revolves around the particular personalities of the main characters. We will share that first:

  • Mom is a super tough lawyer. In a line that may need some explaining to kids, after a crazy event the mother of the two main characters, acting as their lawyer, tells them “Don’t say a word to the police until I get there”.
  • The girl main character Zoe (also very tough) acts like a lawyer and negotiates full immunity from trouble if she tells her mom what happened. Shockingly, mom agrees. A side part of the plot revolves around the parents not allowing Zoe to go to camp for the summer. This resolves well, but at first we are told it “led to weeks of arguments and countless slamming of doors”
  • Dad is described as having a “no shirt, no shoes, no problems” kind of vibe which we are told makes him “a pushover when it comes to discipline”. Later he delivers the most disappointing line in the book when he tells Zoe, “You’re going to pout for however long you’re going to pout. You’re going to… find any chance to pick a fight with your mother. But you’re 13 and we’re your parents, so that’s to be expected”.
  • The beloved grandfather early in the book shares a stereotype as a fact to the kids, “Miami is a sunny place filled with shady people” (one of the kids remarks this is a good thing for the detective agency they are starting). Later he completely lies to distract a security guard to allow kids to sneak in somewhere and sadly refers to it as teaching them journalism. In a similar comment, later the kids ask “Is this a chase?” to which he replies, “No, and if you tell your parents that it was, I’m going to get in a lot of trouble”.
  • Lina, one of the friends, lies bold face to Alex and Zoe’s mom, saying the detective agency was her idea, trying to keep Zoe out of trouble. Zoe thanks her for this lie, to which Lina replies, “what are friends for?”.

Here are a few other things you should be aware of:

  • When talking about jobs, a character calls babysitting boring (also mentioning “bratty kids”), lawn mowing sweaty and cleaning out the attic boring and sweaty. The author uses this to set up the kids forming a detective agency.
  • A character says her father’s love of plants “was almost like a religion to him”
  • There is a reference to climate change. There is a bit here around companies mistreating the earth, but it never goes beyond reasonable bounds.
  • Referring to something that didn’t go well, Zoe’s mom says, “It was a horror show”
  • Near the happy ending, the kids and grandpa decide to omit a part of the overall story mom won’t like
  • The following are referenced in passing: Captain Underpants, Jurassic Park
Our Thoughts

It can be challenging to do a middle-grade mystery well, but this book certainly delivers. While there is a bit of content to be aware of, it is largely clean for young readers.

Here are a few specific things we enjoyed about the start of this series:

  • This mystery starts at the end, which is always a fun format.
  • Probably our favorite thing about this title is the setting. It is based in Miami Florida and you can tell the author spent a lot of time researching (something he shares more about after the story). The setting is different and enjoyable.
  • We also liked the addition of mom being an excellent lawyer who uses her skills to take on cases for people being wronged.
  • The dialogue is funny at times, such as when the kids reply about an accomplishment grandpa brings up, “that was like 9 presidents ago”.
  • The story puts a really positive focus on journalism (outside of the one item we point out above with grandpa’s comment).
  • The plot also brings out some interesting history

This not scary and plenty exciting mystery is one we Recommend.

Plot Summary

Note: This information is typically from the publisher.

Use with caution

In the tradition of Nancy Drew, four kids and one grandfather in Miami tackle a decades-old mystery in this first book in the action-packed and funny Sherlock Society middle grade series from New York Times bestselling, Edgar Award–winning author James Ponti! Siblings Alex and Zoe Sherlock take their last name as inspiration when choosing a summer job. After all, starting a detective agency has to be better than babysitting (boring), lawn mowing (sweaty), or cleaning out the attic (boring and sweaty). Their friends Lina, an avid bookworm, and Yadi, an aspiring cinematographer, join the enterprise, and Alex and Zoe’s retired reporter grandfather offers up his sweet aquamarine Cadillac convertible and storage unit full of cold cases. The group’s first target is the long-lost treasure supposedly hidden near their hometown Miami. Their investigation into the local doings of famed gangster Al Capone leads them to a remote island in the middle of the Everglades where they find alarming evidence hinting at corporate corruption. Together with Grandpa’s know-how and the kids’ intelligence—plus some really slick gadgets—can the Sherlock Society root out the conspiracy?

Purchase Link

Above Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.

Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Christian Review
Good Book Mom
Our Thoughts on this Review

We have said it before, but we really appreciate this site. It is quite literally one of the only Christian review sites we trust to thoroughly review a book from a Christian perspective.

Read Review
Christian Review
Redeemed Reader
Warnings

Christian parents need to know that this site does not attempt to catalog concerning behavior.

Read Review
Christian Review
Plugged In
Warnings

Christian parents should know that while this site does seem to catalog concerning content, it is actually not a focus of the platform and as such falls flat. The categorical breakdown also often loses the overall impact of concerning content.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Do not love the world or anything in the world. If anyone loves the world, love for the Father is not in them. For everything in the world—the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life—comes not from the Father but from the world. The world and its desires pass away, but whoever does the will of God lives forever.

— 1 John 2:15-17