The Puppets of Spelhorst

VERDICT: Avoid

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for The Puppets of Spelhorst

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

This story will surprise many. The feel of the book is not just sad, but seemingly sad for no real purpose. There is death, loneliness, purposelessness and more all told through a short story about a group of puppets. There are no joyful moments. There are no ‘good’ characters, including, for the most part, the puppets themselves. In fact, the young girls at the end of the story are negative and unkind in their interactions (e.g., “she hissed, ‘Martha do this right now or you will regret it.’”). The illustrations also add to the “odd” feel. — There are a few other items to be aware of. There is one use of the word ‘bewitched’ (to mean amazed). The maid, when startled, yells “Saints preserve us!”. A wizard puppet announces a curse during a play. Loving without regret is described as “the greatest glory there is” by one character. — Finally, during a play they get to the point where the boy puppet is ready to rescue the girl puppet who has been taken captive by a wolf. Right at the pivotal moment, in very modern fashion, the girl puppet yells out for the boy puppet not to rescue her, that she doesn’t need it (even though she is captured). She then mocks the boy when he rescues her anyway and is proud of his good deed. It comes across as a sad, unnecessary twist on what many have found to be such a beautiful storyline over the years.

Our Thoughts

Many will probably automatically green-light this book based on the author, who has produced what feels like an endless line of great stories of all types. But like “The Tiger Rising”, we were really not a fan of this one. As with that title, it is not so much that there is any one aspect or item that would cause us to say you absolutely should not read it, but it is also true that there really is no good reason to read it either. It really feels like this attempt at “an original fairy tale” misses the mark, given its intended audience. The book seems like it is certainly aimed at middle grade readers, but it has a sad and heavy type feel from start to finish. It feels like something more “artistic” that a high school honors literature class would be assigned to dig into the deeper meaning behind. All while middle grade kids walk away feeling bummed. This one is an avoid just because we really would not recommend it to any of the children it is aimed for.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

From master storyteller Kate DiCamillo comes an original fairy tale—with enchanting illustrations by Julie Morstad—in which five puppets confront circumstances beyond their control with patience, cunning, and high spirits. — Shut up in a trunk by a taciturn old sea captain with a secret, five friends—a king, a wolf, a girl, a boy, and an owl—bicker, boast, and comfort one another in the dark. Individually, they dream of song and light, freedom and flight, purpose and glory, but they all agree they are part of a larger story, bound each to each by chance, bonded by the heart’s mysteries. When at last their shared fate arrives, landing them on a mantel in a blue room in the home of two little girls, the truth is more astonishing than any of them could have imagined. A beloved author of modern classics draws on her most moving themes with humor, heart, and wisdom in the first of the Norendy Tales, a projected trio of novellas linked by place and mood, each illustrated in black and white by a different virtuoso illustrator. A magical and beautifully packaged gift volume designed to be read aloud and shared, The Puppets of Spelhorst is a tale that soothes and strengthens us on our journey, leading us through whatever dark forest we find ourselves in.

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Kirkus Reviews
Our Thoughts on this Review

Very short high-level overview

Warnings

No discussion on concerning content

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

But test them all; hold on to what is good, reject every kind of evil. May God himself, the God of peace, sanctify you through and through. May your whole spirit, soul and body be kept blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.

— 1 Thessalonians 5:21-23

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews

Christian Review of The Fire, the Water, and Maudie McGinn
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Wayward Creatures
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Ali Cross
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Absolutely Everything: A Graphic Novel
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of White Bird - A Novel (a Wonder Story)
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of My Father’s Words
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Simon Sort of Says
Concern Level: High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of New Dragon City
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Elsie Dinsmore
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of Impossible Creatures
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Treasures of the Snow
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of The Railway Children
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of The Quiet Little Woman: a Christmas Story
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Trapped in a Video Game
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Jack Zulu and the Waylander's Key
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended