The Name of this Book is Secret
VERDICT: Avoid
Concern Level: High

Concern LevelHigh
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
The primary area of concern is the narrator. They glorify lying, at one point saying, “neither was a liar, which was unfortunate. As I am sure you know from experience, lying is an important skill to have. They later give tips on lying. In a similar way they mention “hating manners”. At one point they mention that “grownups have the habit of getting in the way when you want to do something they don’t approve of.” The also joke about core school subjects not really being needed. Late in the book they cut away from what is setting up to be a really nice apology and says, “I prefer to listen in on insults and curses.” They mention that the main characters “acted like heroes… that is to say, foolishly.” Later saying, “you shouldn’t be showing this book to your teacher anyway.” There are mentions of “annoying little brother” and “bossy big sister”. There is a shallow statement about a girl being “the second or third prettiest in the school”. There are strange statements, such as “teeth, as you know from watching television, are very useful when detectives are identifying cadavers” and about enemies, “you know, the ones you say you want to kill, but prefer to keep alive”. Mentions “a remote place where a body might rot and no one would know” and “lying in the kitchen in a pool of blood”. Also mentions a stabbing, misery and death and other threats as well as being burned alive, a cult, alchemy, an Egyptian god, a spinal tap, a sadistic contraption, and drinking monkey blood. One character says, “I hate you” and “I will kill you”. The bad guys plan to extract something from a character’s brain using a tool the Egyptians used to use to “harvest organs.” Mention of someone who “cut out his eyelids”. The main characters lie, deceive guardians, and break into a house. The young girl sees “perfect looking people” and “hates them on sight.” When heading into a dangerous situation she tells someone her plan, “in case they kill me or something.” After a frightening encounter the narrator asks, “have you ever been locked in a room for hours by people you have every reason to believe are capable of murder?” There is also a kidnapping that is described in some detail. A character the kids look up to turns on hip-hop that the kids “were glad their parents weren’t around to hear.” There is a mention of someone dying in a fire very flippantly. Quickly describes one character’s Dad perishing by lightning on a camping trip. During a story when two children are caught stealing they are simply instructed how to steal better. It is never elaborated on, but the main character has “two grandpas” who are always together. They mention to “not tell your mother”. Another character loves to gossip and grandpa loves to listen to it. There are two parents who are held up as comedic characters who have split up over something trivial, but still live in the same split home, completely ignoring each other. Later the book seems to be about to present a ‘happy ending’ for these two, which it presents as a ‘proper divorce’. There is also a “magician” character as well as hypnotism.
VerdictAvoid
Our Thoughts
It is easy to see the parallels between this book and the Series of Unfortunate Events series. The biggest similarity is a mysterious narrator who acts as a part of the story. The big (and incredibly unfortunate) difference is that in this book the narrator is an awful moral influence on the young readers this series targets. This really is itself unfortunate, because the book is a clever, intriguing and at times funny story about two quirky outsiders who find each other and become close friends while working to solve a mystery. The purposely immoral nature of this story that is encouraged by the narrator and the loads of concerning content makes this one a solid “avoid” for Christian families
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
Warning: this description has not been authorized by Pseudonymous Bosch. As much as he'd love to sing the praises of his book (he is very vain), he wouldn't want you to hear about his brave 11-year old heroes, Cass and Max-Ernest. Or about how a mysterious box of vials, the Symphony of Smells, sends them on the trail of a magician who has vanished under strange (and stinky) circumstances. And he certainly wouldn't want you to know about the hair-raising adventures that follow and the nefarious villains they face. You see, not only is the name of this book secret, the story inside is, too. For it concerns a secret. A Big Secret.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books
While this site can often be helpful to identify concerning aspects of books, sadly, this one is yet another example of why this site simply cannot be trusted by Christian parents for their book reviews. All of what is pointed out above in the Concerning Content is instead given a simple, “Parents need to know that there is little to be concerned about here: one mild expletive, some indirectly referenced violence, and children sneaking out on adventures.”
Read ReviewLet the message of Christ dwell among you richly as you teach and admonish one another with all wisdom through psalms, hymns, and songs from the Spirit, singing to God with gratitude in your hearts. And whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him.
— Colossians 3:16-17
More Christian Parent Reviews














