See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

The Hunger Games

VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider

Concern Level: High

Book Cover for The Hunger Games

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

The crux of the concerning content revolves around the games where children from a number of different districts are placed into an environment (an arena) and forced to hunt each other to the death. This is organized by a government (the Capital) that wants to ensure the Districts know the Capital is fully in control and remind them what it would be like if the districts chose to rebel again. The Capital controls the environment so even someone who tried to hide and not fight would eventually be taken out by them. In fact, the Capital takes steps to draw contestants together at various stages. All this while everyone in society watches the “games” on TV in a live reality show format. The violence is certainly described, but potentially not what some people would call “gory”. Right away a young boy dies in front of Katniss via a knife in the back (the boy coughs blood all over her). She looks and sees several kids fighting to the death and as well as several already lying dead. In later parts of the story a boy’s neck is snapped, a spear is driven through a young girl, another young boy is also killed by a spear, an arrow is put through a young man’s neck. There is a forest fire Katniss has to run from for her life, mutated insects that cause death or madness and mutated wolves appear that Katniss believes are somehow made from the previously deceased contestants (besides the insects and wolves, most everything feels “this worldly”). One character is mauled by these wolves and the violence is again described, but attempts to be non-gory. — The society, of which the games are one part, is shown to be terrible. This has hardened the main character and the author shows this in several ways. Very early in the book she says that she nearly drowned a cat her young sister brought home because she couldn’t afford another mouth to feed. Her father died (“blown to bits” and “buried alive”) in a mining accident and this has caused her mother to nearly completely check out, ruining her relationship and trust with her. She supports her family by hunting illegally and selling what she hunted in a black-market area. She also has times of making darker comments like, “If we have to choose between starving and a bullet to the head, the bullet is much faster.” She assumes the worst in other people’s motives and even takes steps to counter what she assumes they are doing. At one point she gets so low she welcomes death. During the games there is a lot of lying and deception to manipulate sponsors into sending aid (this is never completely shown as wrong or viewed in a negative light). And while this may be sold as being “understandable” Katniss does not act like a total victim. There are multiple times when she takes an active role in trying to take the initiative to take out other contestants (e.g., when she gets a new weapon and looks forward to using it). Katniss mentions that she won’t get married as she is not willing to bring kids into the world of the games (the kids would be in a pool to potentially be selected). — Other items include a very vivid fear-focused hallucination due to a string from one of the insects mentioned above. There are servants who are described as being those who were caught committing a crime and had their tongues cut out. — Katniss tries wine, justifying that she may not get another chance. She immediately feels the effects and stops. Another character is known for being a drunk. At one point he tries to hug a lady who turns away disgusted and Katniss replies that she bets she will try and get a new assignment where, “drunks don’t try and molest you in front of the entire nation.” Later this man gets sick to his stomach and falls down in it. — Katniss and a male friend (who she has some confused feelings for) are alone a lot out in the woods during the initial “normal life” portion of the book (they are catching food to survive together). Later Katniss shares a sleeping bag with a boy, but there is no hint of anything sexual and at this point they are both typically hanging on by a thread and this is seen as last-ditch survival (for warmth). Katniss and the boy tribute from her district kiss multiple times (this is a part of the deception to the sponsors discussed above). — One part of the games is very sensational outfits for the contestants. One character is said to have been given a “sexy” look and appears in a completely see-through dress. Later when Katniss is given a dress, she immediately notices padding was added to her chest area (the word “breasts” is used). The designer (who she has befriended) says it was a compromise because the Capital wanted to “surgically alter” her. There are a couple times where it mentions something along the lines of “stripping off my shirt and pants and climbing into bed in my underwear” (again, not meant to be sexual, but may impact decision for your reader) — Finally some of the scattered language is very direct and poignant: blood bath, cannibalism (said, but not done in the story), slitting throats, bludgeoning one another to death, quiet bloodless deaths (e.g., freezing), bash head, wait for the blood to begin to flow, kill viciously, “I wonder if she will enjoy watching me die”. At the end the character’s look to be ready to commit suicide, but we are not sure if they would have gone through with it. There are also a few mentions of idiots and “sexy” and a few “gross” references, such as when she says she cleans her kill and throws the “entrails” to the cat.

Our Thoughts

The first thing to say right up front is that this is not a book for any young to middle aged children. Please don’t think that because you have allowed a child to watch movies with lightsaber battles and heroes battling villains that they are automatically ready for this title. As for the most mature teenagers… well that is going to be a decision parents will really need to wrestle with. Many may be surprised by the “Prayerfully Consider” verdict for this title, and that is fair. This was a tough decision. But for a title targeting much older audiences (this title should appear in the “Young Adult” section in libraries) it has a relatively small amount of immoral content. The target audience does matter. Much “Young Adult” content borderlines on pornography. That is not at all the case here. The primary concern here is obviously the violence. This reminds us a lot of the war movies where a producer/director has decided to remind us that war is not a game. Or the Dark Knight series of movies where a brilliant director decides to show us just how evil a city really can get (think of Sodom and Gomorrah). Here the author invites us into a dystopian world to envision what gladiator matches (something the earliest Christians did experience) would be like in our day of technology, especially if a powerful government wanted to send a clear message to a people who had previously rebelled. The actual “action” of the “games” takes up a relatively small portion of the book, but it is hard to overstate just how intense it could feel to a child who can likely easily see themselves in the shoes of a child selected and forced into an impossible situation (especially since the main character arrives there after stepping in to rescue their younger sister). You feel like you are there, hiding, not knowing what is coming next. The author walks a line to accomplish this, avoiding being overly graphic, but certainly writing plenty to show you just how awful this is (see examples above). This book has many positives. It is very entertaining, it shines a light onto societal dangers & affluence, there are multiple beautiful and captivating acts of self-sacrifice, some character growth and examples of friendship… but none of this is enough to warrant turning a blind eye to everything above. At the end of the day, this decision needs to come down to whether or not you believe your older, mature teenager is ready for and should read this title. It is something to very carefully prayerfully consider. — Finally, for those looking for a lighter dystopian, consider checking out reviews for The City of Ember (reviewed on this site), The Giver and similar titles to see if they may be a better fit. Even better, check out faith-building examples like “The Architect” and “Kingdom’s Dawn” (also both reviewed on this site).

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

In the ruins of a place once known as North America lies the nation of Panem, a shining Capitol surrounded by twelve outlying districts. The Capitol is harsh and cruel and keeps the districts in line by forcing them all to send one boy and one girl between the ages of twelve and eighteen to participate in the annual Hunger Games, a fight to the death on live TV. Sixteen-year-old Katniss Everdeen, who lives alone with her mother and younger sister, regards it as a death sentence when she steps forward to take her sister's place in the Games. But Katniss has been close to dead before—and survival, for her, is second nature. Without really meaning to, she becomes a contender. But if she is to win, she will have to start making choices that weight survival against humanity and life against love

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Christian Review
The Gospel Coalition
Our Thoughts on this Review

Really interesting perspective. Be sure to read through this one for great conversation starters you may not think of at first.

Read Review
Christian Review
Redeemed Reader
Our Thoughts on this Review

Solid review worth a read.

Read Review
Christian Review
Plugged In
Our Thoughts on this Review

Plot summary type review.

Warnings

While we are thankful for Plugged In, we are not a fan of this review and others like it.

Read Review
Christian Review
Good Books for Catholic Kids
Our Thoughts on this Review

Solid review from a Catholic source. Includes notes on the full trilogy.

Read Review
Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Common Sense Media
Warnings

A reminder that Common Sense Media is a secular site we often have to give serious warnings about. While this review is safer than others that touch on topics outside of violence, we still see major issues in the “Positive Role Models” and “Violence” ratings.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

For you were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord. Live as children of light (for the fruit of the light consists in all goodness, righteousness and truth) and find out what pleases the Lord. Have nothing to do with the fruitless deeds of darkness, but rather expose them.

— Ephesians 5:8-11

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews