Concern Level: Medium
Many stories have a critical moment where a young child feels it necessary to sneak out of the house or make a secret call or something similar. But ... → Continue reading below
The Experiment
VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
Many stories have a critical moment where a young child feels it necessary to sneak out of the house or make a secret call or something similar. But there are stories like this one that take this type of thing to another level. Here there is a lot of deceptive behavior throughout and it there is no feel of repentance or even feeling bad. We will give a list of the majority of it here so you can understand. A girl sits at an air vent to eavesdrop on parent’s conversation. Nathan (the main character) has a secret phone and uses it to text another girl in a similar situation as himself. He hides things and often lies to his parents. There is quite a bit of sneaking around in ways that would be very dangerous in real life. Nathan and Victor want to make sure Nathan’s parents don’t hear a conversation so they push chairs in front of his bedroom door to prevent them from coming in. Nathan recalls a long list of sneaky things he has done in the past in the context of getting upset at his cat for always alerting his mom of the deceptive behavior (a good example of no repentance). He justifies dishonesty at one point saying, “It was all true, technically”. Other things to be aware of: Nathan describes “easy going” as “immune to annoying people” We see “OMG” in a text and hear of “eye-rolling” Several things are ascribed to “luck” In a moment of intense anger, Nathan envisions hurting his cat Victor’s grandma, who is intended to be wise, explains that a “mean streak” comes from unhappiness, which isn’t totally wrong, but isn’t the whole story from a Christian perspective. Nathan describes playing “dumb phone games” as “normal sixth-grade behavior” Dad tells Nathan that video games were his mom’s “secret addiction” Young readers will see the very dangerous and misguided statement that Nathan’s mom “had told him her truth… but Nathan’s truth and his parent’s truth might not be the same thing” The term “idiot” is used Also misleading, children will see in this one, “Every bird on earth is a descendant of the last dinosaur” For your awareness, the following references are made: Calvin and Hobbs, comic books (held in a positive light here, despite them being on average very dark today), Star Trek, Harry Potter, Guardians of the Galaxy
VerdictPrayerfully Consider
Our Thoughts
This one starts off with a mysterious dystopian vibe from the start. Honestly, it was one of the first times in quite a while that we were genuinely intrigued, trying to figure out where in the world (no pun intended) this story was headed. There is a bit of an ‘odd’ feel of the story as it goes on that some young readers (e.g., those who enjoy sci-fi type stories) will enjoy and others won’t care for. Specific things we liked: This book was intriguing as you try and figure out the plot. Friendship is shown in a positive light in the relationship between Nathan and Victor, who really care for each other. Nathan’s friend Victor is by far the kindest, most positive character (by a long measure). His family is also very welcoming and kind. Fortunately, the book references them as going to church on Sundays. Overall, there is enough in the concerning content section (and not a ton of positive content to offset it) that we decided to mark this as a Prayerfully Consider.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
Nathan never understood what was "fun" about secrets, probably because he’s always had to keep a very big one. Although he appears to be a typical sixth-grader (with parents, homework and a best friend, Victor), Nathan learned at an early age that his family is from another planet. Now, their time on Earth may be coming to an end. Nathan, his parents and nine other families are part of an experiment that suddenly seems to be going wrong. Some of the experimenters, including Nathan's first crush, Izzy, are disappearing without a word. After his family is called back to the mothership, Nathan begins to question everything he’s been taught to believe about who he is and why he's on Earth. The Experiment is a fast-paced coming-of-age novel - with aliens - that asks universal questions about how we figure out who we want to be, and whether it’s ever too late to change.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
Man, we really want to appreciate and like this site and other review sites like it that at least mention Christianity, but “reviews” like this that put no effort towards concerning content (see “Considerations: none” here) are almost as disappointing and sad to us as the blatant secular ones we often include to warn Christian parents. Really disappointing.
Read ReviewBe alert and of sober mind. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour. Resist him, standing firm in the faith, because you know that the family of believers throughout the world is undergoing the same kind of sufferings.
— 1 Peter 5:8-9
More Christian Parent Reviews