Concern Level: Medium-Low
The biggest thing for Christian parents to know is that this short title attempts to tackle a bit heavier subject, loss, in a light and kid-appropriat... → Continue reading below
Saving Winslow
VERDICT: Recommended
(with caution)
Concern Level: Medium-Low

Concern LevelMedium-Low
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
The biggest thing for Christian parents to know is that this short title attempts to tackle a bit heavier subject, loss, in a light and kid-appropriate way. The context leads to a good bit of matter-of-fact discussion around farm animals dying. It starts nearly immediately. This becomes the backdrop of discussion of various types of loss through the eyes of kids. Louis (the main character) and his parents have a deep sadness due to his older brother Gus going off to join the Army. Nora (another key character) reveals her brother did not survive birth (something that nearly happened to Louis himself). The main plot revolves around Winslow (a donkey) who is sickly and is not supposed to make it. Nora’s dog passed away in the past. It is handled intentionally and carefully, but this may or may not be a good for your young reader. There is a small amount of ‘violent’ content, but it falls into the type of thing that happens regularly on farms. For example, Louis’ uncle tells them very matter-of-factly that a "coyote had taken one of the newborn lambs… Terrible, terrible sight what was left behind… Blood and mess and traumatized sheep”. Louis' friend Mack falls for Nora’s sister. There is a bit of content about this relationship. At one point Mack says they have been “smooching”. In frustration, Louis unleashes a string of comments like “stupid animal control”. A rude neighbor yells ‘shut up” many times. When Louis reaches the end of his rope, he unloads and yells back in a very disrespectful way. To make it much worse, Dad is right there and only makes very weak comments (“Now, now” and “Louis…”) with no discipline. A few other things to know about: One of Gus’ letters to Louis says “Don’t tell mom”. Later Louis is embarrassed and says the same thing to Gus. Neither are meant to be very deceptive, but obviously wish this wasn’t included. A ray of sunlight shows and Nora says, “That’s an angel at work… Everyone knows that.”
VerdictRecommended
Our Thoughts
For kids who are ready for a story on the topic of loss, and it is handled well, this is a sweet read. If it was any heavier, we likely wouldn’t recommend it, as handling a topic this important without Christ leaves a huge gospel-sized hole. Obviously, we wish a Kingdom-focus was there, but for a secular book it is well done. Young readers will pull for Louis, who we can tell has had it a bit rough since birth and now shares his huge heart with the donkey no one else gives a chance (we even see Louis drop a bag with a couple or rolls and a candy bar to a homeless man). Similarly, they will read hoping to see the real Nora, the young girl who is a skeptic towards everything in order to protect herself from any further hurt, come out of her protective shell and blossom. In this sense, the ending is a good one. This is a book we Recommend for Christian parents who believe their kiddo is ready for it.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
Indie Next List Pick · ALA Notable Children’s Book · Texas Bluebonnet Award Winner “A winning tale of love.” —Kirkus (starred review) Perfect for fans of Charlotte’s Web and The One and Only Ivan, Saving Winslow is an uplifting modern classic in the making about a young boy who befriends an ailing newborn donkey and nurses him back to health, from New York Times bestseller and Newbery Medal winner Sharon Creech. Louie doesn't have the best luck when it comes to nurturing small creatures. So when his father brings home a sickly newborn mini donkey, he's determined to save him. He names him Winslow. Taking care of him helps Louie feel closer to his brother, Gus, who is far, far away in the army. Everyone worries that Winslow won't survive, especially Louie’s quirky new friend, Nora, who has experienced loss of her own. But as Louie's bond with Winslow grows, surprising and life-altering events prove that this fragile donkey is stronger than anyone could have imagined. Written in the spirit of Creech favorites Moo and Love That Dog, this standout tale about love and friendship and letting go will tug at the heartstrings. “This heartwarming story is sure to be a hit with fans of E. B. White’s Charlotte’s Web and Kate DiCamillo’s Because of Winn-Dixie.” —School Library Journal (starred review) “Creech packs a tremendous amount of emotion between the lines of her understated prose. Animal lovers in particular will relish Louie’s hard-won triumphs and find joy in Winslow’s strength.” —Publishers Weekly (starred review) “Woven into this narrative is a convincing portrayal of human growth and blossoming—the story is told simply but subtly, celebrating the unexpected strength of the vulnerable.” —Horn Book (starred review)
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
Be alert and of sober mind. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour. Resist him, standing firm in the faith, because you know that the family of believers throughout the world is undergoing the same kind of sufferings.
— 1 Peter 5:8-9
More Christian Parent Reviews