Concern Level: Medium
An adult authority figure tells Penny, the main character, that something is “our little secret”. Here it is meant to be a kind gesture about a candy... → Continue reading below
Penny Draws a Best Friend
VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
An adult authority figure tells Penny, the main character, that something is “our little secret”. Here it is meant to be a kind gesture about a candy jar, but this is obviously a very dangerous concept to introduce to a child. This is a good reminder to talk with your children about anyone guiding them to not tell you something, especially other adults. Penny is a hyper-worried child. All throughout the book she jumps to worst case scenarios. While the book feels light, there are a few times when we read her worries and they include a few things like “what if my mom has been kidnapped”, wondering if her mom has “fallen in love with a man in prison and is visiting him there” (mentions the term “love affair”) and worrying her parents are getting divorced. In one unfortunate comment related to divorce, Penny flippantly says that “ugh, two Christmas’ would stress me out”, which drastically underplays just how devastating divorce is on a child and family. At one point when Penny is worried what will happen at a sleepover she imagines the girls wanting to drink coffee and watch R-rated movies (seems to imply she would cave and do it too). They do end up playing truth-or-dare, which Penny doesn’t want to at all, but does anyway. Penny lies somewhat frequently, almost always to avoid telling her mom something she doesn’t want to share. Towards the end when the group of new friends is supposed to be visiting the Feelings Teacher they end up meeting somewhere else and hanging out (never shown as wrong). There are other examples, such as drinking a soda even though she knows she is not allowed. A big part of this story revolves around Penny and her eventual friends going to see a “feelings teacher”. At first we weren’t sure what to make of it, but it ended up being a helpful guidance counselor. Obviously we would want our children relying on us primarily, not something that happens in this book, so that is a good reminder on something to speak to your kiddo about.. Other potentially concerning content: Mentions “dancing like famous TikTokers” and later YouTube is referenced a few times. A girl is shown saying, “whatever”. Penny says that a lot of kids want a phone to “play Roblox” and “look up bad words”. Penny herself ends up with a phone at a very young age (meant to comfort her in times of worry). Halloween is referenced a couple times in a positive light. A couple references to “werewolf” and a haunted house. A hamster is said to have ‘devil eyes’. A truck is said to look like a zombie. A friend’s brother scares them by telling them there is a ghost in the house. One child shares that “There’s a creature in my woods. It howls at night”. Some gossiping is shown. On seeing a picture of a leopard we hear the comment, “that thing could rip your guts out”. Penny asks her dog if something is “better than getting your butt scratched”. Later we hear about her dog smelling other dogs' butts a couple times. We also hear a reference to “a mysterious fart smell”. Multiple references to “throwing up”. The term “boogers” is used.
VerdictPrayerfully Consider
Our Thoughts
When we first started reviewing this book and saw some of the early concerning content items we listed above, we assumed this book was going to fall right in line with many of the graphic novels we have suggested Christian parents avoid. But this book is different. It is absolutely true that there is unfortunate and unnecessary content here that Christian parents will wish had not been included (detailed above), but it is also true that this book at its core is sweet and holds quite a bit of positive content, especially compared to much of other graphic novel options. The main character Penny is a sensitive, hyper-worried girl. We see her wrestle with her best friend transitioning to someone who is no longer good for Penny to be around. We see, in that ‘friend’s’ place, a group of unlikely friends come alongside her and show her acceptance and love. One of these friends is described as ‘cool and popular because she is so nice’ (a great contrast to the friend she is losing’. This book ends up being funny and cute and sweet, especially in its format of delivery… Penny writing to her dog Cosmo. So what to do? There is quite a bit of potentially concerning content above that needs to be considered (especially considering the short format). if you believe your particular kiddo can look past the concerning content above without being negatively impacted by it and focus on the good in this book, or even better if you are willing to read it to or alongside your kiddo so you can point out things and use them as teaching moments, then this is certainly a book and start of a series to consider. We give this one a ‘Prayerfully Consider’.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
How come Violet is suddenly not into drawing? Who etched the words ‘I Am Bug Man’ inside my desk? Why is Mom suddenly acting like she has a secret? Nobody said starting the last year of primary school would be easy, and Penny Lowry’s anxiety means a million questions are always spinning through her thoughts. Luckily she’s got a lot to look forward to, like her favourite after-school activity, Art Club, and seeing her best friend Violet again after spending the whole summer apart. The thing is, Violet has been acting weird ever since she got back. She never wants to hang out anymore, she says Art Club is for babies, and she spends all her time with Riley, the meanest girl in school. Did Penny do something wrong? And if she did, can she undo it? In this sweet, tender and funny introduction to a lovable kid figuring out how to manage her anxiety, the author of the #1 bestselling Pretty Little Liars series gets to the heart of how to let go of the friends who aren’t right for you—and how to make room for the ones who are.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
How can a young person stay on the path of purity? By living according to your word. I seek you with all my heart; do not let me stray from your commands. I have hidden your word in my heart that I might not sin against you. Praise be to you, Lord; teach me your decrees. With my lips I recount all the laws that come from your mouth. I rejoice in following your statutes as one rejoices in great riches. I meditate on your precepts and consider your ways. I delight in your decrees; I will not neglect your word.
— Psalm 119:9-16
More Christian Parent Reviews