See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

Misfit Mansion

VERDICT: Avoid

Concern Level: High

Book Cover for Misfit Mansion

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

What’s behind those cute smiling faces on the cover? An illustrated horror book that attempts to jump back and forth between life lessons and disturbing (not an understatement) content. So there’s that…

We see this dynamic right away. We have two completely normal looking pages and then all of a sudden a frightening image of a horror creature stares up at the reader smiling creepily on page 3 out of nowhere. You shouldn’t really need to hear anything else, but here is a taste of what else lurks in these pages:

  • The book is based around a mansion filled with “horrors”, all illustrated for young readers. This place is described as “a refuge for any horror in need – ghosts, monsters… you name it”.
  • The book flips back and forth between trying to make these creatures feel sweet and good and then over and over, out of nowhere a really dark and evil image will appear. These things get creepy… like WAY creepier than you would expect from the cover.
  • One of the worst points in the book delivers really sad and dangerous messaging. The human who keeps these horrors locked up tells them humans are scared of them. When they escape, one of them turns each item in a top shop into genuinely evil looking versions of themselves. No cuteness here. Just dark and evil. Sadly the author has a group of shoppers come in and buy all this up, super excited to have new product and loving each item. The message comes across that the humans actually just love all the creepy and evil stuff (“But the humans clearly love creepy stuff!” and “the humans like scary stuff”).
  • In a weird addition, there are points where the author presents horrors like they are some underrepresented and persecuted minority group.
  • A line flippantly reads, “though you never know with ghost possessions”. There are references to a biker gang and witch magic.
  • The town has a creepy festival. School has a related haunted house.
  • When leaving the house to go into town, one horror almost joyfully suggests, “Let’s give them a genuine horror experience! You guys can possess stuff, right?”.

This is all just a taste.

Note: Please don’t underestimate how creepy and evil the scenes we reference sprinkled throughout the book really are. We pray no young children will even flip through this colorfully illustrated book that will inevitably be in the young children’s section at libraries and stores.

Our Thoughts

Maybe surprisingly to many, we don’t review a lot of horror related books. Why? Because the covers typically very clearly show what is inside. There is little to wonder. If Christian parents are willing to compromise after seeing a cover like those typically used, we doubt there is much we would say in a review that would change their minds. So why review this one? A few reasons. First, it really saddens us to see the content that is being placed in these “graphic novel” format books. As they grow in popularity, there seems to be no end to what publishers will place in them (just search graphic novel on our site and read through some of the other ‘Avoid’ books we have gone through). Second, this cover is misleading… at least partially. We still believe that this should not be a book Christian should consider, but we admit that the happy, smiling faces on the cover could easily draw a child or parent into thinking the content inside matched this sentiment. It does not. And that brings us to our third point. The attempt to mix lessons on family and happy vibes with horror is just at its core wrong. Completely wrong. It is a perversion of those beautiful and wonderful things God has given us. Finally, we are completely saddened to see this on the shelf/list for one of the esteemed state reader lists. And so this review…

We pray this helps keep this book out of the hands of Christian children. This is a clear Avoid for Christians.

Plot Summary

Note: This information is typically from the publisher.

Use with caution

Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends meets Hilda and the Troll in this spooky and sweet middle grade graphic novel about a monster girl who sneaks out of her foster home and into a human town in search of a forever family but finds more than she bargained for.

Despite her monstrous appearance, Iris has never felt like she belongs in a mansion filled with kelpies and gorgons and unicorns. She longs to find a family. Unfortunately, she and her housemates are trapped in a “foster home for horrors” run by former paranormal investigator Mr. Halloway. So, when a human boy named Mathias breaks the house’s sealing spell, Iris and her companions are set free upon the town of Dead End Springs.

What Iris doesn’t know is that Mathias is also a paranormal hunter (the kind who seeks to capture and destroy the horrors), or that there are other dangers ahead. As Iris searches for a home, she makes human friends, explores a brand-new world…and stumbles upon a dark secret that Halloway has kept locked in the basement of the house. Will this long-slumbering mystery destroy the family Iris so desperately seeks?

Purchase Link

Above Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.

No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
cannonball read
Warnings

Adding this as a huge and glaring reminder of why Christian parents need to rely on faithful, detailed Christian review sources.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Keep this Book of the Law always on your lips; meditate on it day and night, so that you may be careful to do everything written in it. Then you will be prosperous and successful. Have I not commanded you? Be strong and courageous. Do not be afraid; do not be discouraged, for the Lord your God will be with you wherever you go.

— Joshua 1:8-9