Concern Level: Medium
Most of this book is very “this worldly”, but the plot does have a key aspect of it that falls a bit into the mysterious and magical category. And it... → Continue reading below
Isle of Ever
VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
Most of this book is very “this worldly”, but the plot does have a key aspect of it that falls a bit into the mysterious and magical category. And it is here that we find the biggest concern item for Christian parents. While it doesn’t come across as necessarily “dark”, there is a character brought up in flashbacks about key past events who is said to have the “gift of sight”, which is eventually referred to as “premonition” (seeing glimpses into the future). Another key plot item is when the town believes (and is later proven to be ‘right’ about) many strange things happening whenever a “blood moon” (a very rare astrological event) occurs. The Bible clearly tells us to be cautious with this type of thing so Christian parents will need to carefully determine where this particular example falls. A few other items come up that Christian parents won’t like to see included: Benny complains, “who wanted to text someone whose mom could be reading their messages”. Benny’s grandma tells her something important is a secret and tells her not to tell her mother (“this is our secret Guppy”). Another grandma says, “I may let you keep your phone in your room at night and buy you unlimited Oreo packages… even though your parents told me not to”. A sign says, “Grandma rules apply here”. Similarly, Evelyn's papa says, “We won’t tell your mother that part” (meant to not worry her, but still). There is some confusing and misleading “spiritual” content. In a desperate situation someone says, “I knew we needed more than prayers now. We needed a miracle… I knew just where to find one”. A strange event is called a “bad omen”. Another line says, “feels like we ticked off the gods or something”. Other concerning / potentially concerning aspects to consider when deciding: We open to friends out on an adventure casually telling each other where each had deceptively told their parents they were going (“we only told a small fib for a very good reason”). Later another character sneaks out. Zara tells a man not to tell her grandma she went out and “borrowed” her keys without asking. A boy pretends to faith to deceive his dad. A crime show on TV mentions a murder A nice business owner jokes about flooding his own restaurant for the insurance money Climate change is proposed as a possible reason an island is missing The following terms/phrases are used: “holy crap”, “may luck help you”, “God” (used flippantly), “this sounds like the start of every horror movie”, “sure as hell won’t”, “if you break something Evelyn is going to haunt you”, a friend’s eyes are said to “sparkle with mischief”, “she could call it fate, call it luck, but the things that were happening now were no accident”, “badass”, “pissing off”, idiot, jerk (note: quite a bit of the language comes near the very end of the book). The following items are referenced: Taylor Swift, Ready Player One (we have not reviewed the book, but the movie has a horror movie related portion to it).
VerdictPrayerfully Consider
Our Thoughts
Some authors know how to draw readers in. If you aren’t intrigued by the really interesting cover image, or the mysterious journal entry and map that follows it, or maybe even the attention-grabbing prologue, the first chapter will almost assuredly get you. This mystery for kids really does have a killer intro, culminating with the introduction of a high stakes game of sorts. The question for Christian parents is whether they want their kiddos being drawn in. The primary concern above is certainly one to prayerfully wrestle with. And unfortunately there is a good bit more we wish had been left out. If you decide to let them read it, we would suggest you only do it if you are willing to be intentional and discuss things like "premonitions" and other similar items (such as communicating with the dead) that we often see lightly introduced in children’s books in a secular framework. Similarly, our kids need to know that no one should ever tell them not to share something with their parents. With all of that in mind, we have this one as a Prayerfully Consider for Christian families.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
Bestselling and beloved author Jen Calonita delivers the first in a brand new series featuring a girl who will inherit a mysterious fortune if she can break a centuries-old curse! Days after her twelfth birthday, Everly "Benny" Benedict learns she's the heir to a fortune! But to collect the inheritance, she first has to play—and win—a game. Following clues that her ancestor left, Benny must locate a small island that vanished long ago, according to legend. She has only two weeks to play the game and find the island. If she's successful, she'll break a two-hundred-year-old curse. If she fails, the fortune will be forfeited. And if she's not careful, she'll cross paths with someone else who is after the island's secrets, and who will stop at nothing to get them. Because, as it turns out, there's far more than a fortune at stake.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
Adding this review as a reminder of why Christians need Christian review sources (CSM is a secular site).
Read ReviewEnter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it. Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves.
— Matthew 7:13-14
More Christian Parent Reviews