See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

History Comics: Ellis Island

VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider

Concern Level: Medium-Low

Book Cover for History Comics: Ellis Island

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

This entry in this series naturally turns attention to immigration. Some will feel the book dips its toes into the surrounding debate on this topic in our country today (see the section below for more on this from a Christian perspective, here we simply make you aware of it). We see the sign showing “Give me your tired, poor…” and someone comments “That still sounds relevant to what’s going on these days!” to which the response comes, “you’re right”. One page shows a drawing representing the very small number of people turned away at Ellis Island. For a few pages this pro-immigration message picks up focus a bit. For example, someone comments, “There are those who support immigrants, documented or otherwise, but there are those who see them as a threat” to which it gets added, “Ironic since the United States was founded by immigrants”. At best this oversimplifies a complex topic for a nation to consider. Make sure to speak with your kids about the full picture here from a Christian perspective if you do let them read this. We should also note that to expand on this the author makes it a point to include, “you would be denied entry to the US if you were gay or transgender” and it shows two men with one crying. During a historical account we hear some details that might disturb some readers. A pirate was hung at Ellis Island. Others as well. We see a simple illustration showing two hanging, but not much detail (it is zoomed out). When displaying reasons why people immigrated into the U.S. we see a drawing of people forced against a wall with a machine gun turned on them. When civil war is brought up a couple of killed soldiers are shown in an illustration. Other things to be aware of: During a storm someone says, “This is apocalyptic. Maybe it’s the end of the world” to which another replies, “I read the Maya predicted it would happen this year”. The storm is referred to as a “Frankenstorm”. Someone comments, “Mother nature can be a tough cookie”. A character requests “No horror stories, please” when campfire stories come up. A boy is shown with a skull on his jacket. A mom comments, “you are usually too busy playing video games” to explain why thy missed something. A small kiss is exchanged between two adults in a drawing. The author’s note sadly mentions “The Godfather” films in a series targeted at children.

Our Thoughts

As you see above this book weighs in on immigration in a graphic novel placed in front of our kids. It brings up an interesting discussion topic. As Christian parents we need to view each and every complex topic through the lens of our faith. When it comes to immigration, nations have a lot to weigh and consider. There is no doubt. But there is also our job as believers to demonstrate the gospel to everyone. We can vote and influence and support our nation’s policies… but when and if people find themselves in desperate situations, God will call on His people to respond. We need to share all of this with our children so God’s will doesn’t get lost in political back and forth. Our loyalty is to our Creator and King. Here are a few more positives about the title while considering in everything in the previous section. Many people will be excited about the idea of using kids natural attraction to graphic novels and using them for educational purposes. Like historical fiction, this does get kids thinking. What was it like to come over to a new land? Why was there such an influx? For the most part, the art really captures the audience and we open with a child character, which helps. We do see people praying to be strong when entering a new land and a new life, with illustrations showing them down on their knees. There is also a reference woven in to the Tower of Babel. We have this one as a Prayerfully Consider. Honestly this one seems like a series we would have caution on as a whole, encouraging parents to carefully consider each book they allow their child read. It seems like each could bring up complex topics like this one did (all in a format you likely wouldn’t expect it). Note: If you decide to let them read this, depending on your reader, you may want to have your child skip the interesting, but dry history section up front and come back to it so you don’t lose their attention up front, allowing them to jump into the pretty pictures and comic-like format.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

Turn back the clock with History Comics! In this volume, take a visit to Ellis Island and learn America's immigration story. Many Americans know someone who can trace their ancestry through Ellis Island. In addition to being part of the world-famous Statue of Liberty National Monument, this modest-sized piece of land once housed the main immigration processing center for the U.S., documenting upwards of 12 million people between 1892 and 1954! Over the generations, Ellis Island has taken on an almost mythic status as a beacon of hope to those seeking freedom and refuge from persecution. But how did it all get started? Our past is only the beginning with History Comics, a riveting nonfiction graphic novel series from First Second!

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link

Scripture Reflection

For though we live in the world, we do not wage war as the world does. The weapons we fight with are not the weapons of the world. On the contrary, they have divine power to demolish strongholds. We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.

— 2 Corinthians 10:3-5

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews