Concern Level: Medium
There is a large focus on “green magic” or “plant magic”. At one point Daisy asks, “Isn’t that nature”, to which the reply comes, “everything in natu... → Continue reading below
Greenwild: The World Behind the Door
VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
There is a large focus on “green magic” or “plant magic”. At one point Daisy asks, “Isn’t that nature”, to which the reply comes, “everything in nature is magic”. While this may not seem like the biggest deal in the world the theme is pervasive and it does lean towards one of the worst things we can do… honor the creation and leave out the Creator. An example of this are multiple exclamations of “Thank greenness”. One of the more likable characters soon reveals he has “two dads”. For example, the young reader reads, “Neither of my two dads are great cooks” and near the end “Daisy, these are my two dads”. They are referred to as “husbands”. To show how wrong and confusing this is we are told one is called dad and the other papa. Mom drinks sparkling champagne at night. A teacher tells a class a plant is “wonderful in cocktails” and winks. A celebration has plum wine and people start singing “drinking songs”. We hear other instances of wine and of pints of ale. The acknowledgements also mention “champaign”. In a bit of a heavy moment, we find out Daisy’s father died in a car crash when she was young. Later a past evil is recalled and we are told an evil man committed murder. In a backstory we hear of a family “attacked and murdered”. An evil man kills a parakeet by crushing its head and a bit of detail is shown. A wicked lady takes Daisy captive with a knife to her throat. Mom brings up “climate” and there are quick mentions of floods, fires, endangered species in the conversation, implying a connection. We are also told Ma is an international journalist, but she tries to avoid flying because it is bad for the environment. The young reader is later told, “There’s big money in destroying the earth, Daisy: pumping for oil, planting crops for livestock on pristine rainforest land, mining for minerals, selling rare specimens for profit… always pushing for more destruction”. Other items for Christian parents to know about: Mom attributes a rescue to their being lucky. There are instances of wishes, wishing and magic. We read of wishing on a tree for someone’s safety. In fact the culminating ending revolves around making a wish. A plan it called a “suicide palm” and another is a “vampire orchid”. When listing her “skills” Daisy includes pickpocketing and adds that her mom is not aware of that one. A fragrant garden’s scent is said to be “like witchcraft”. A mean dog is called a “demon hound”. Journalists are said to be “gossiping”. Bad guys are said to “swear”, but words are not shown. A guard is said to be “swearing filthily”. In fondly remembering a past friend we are told she was an “extravagant liar… involved Daisy… stealing small coins from the pockets of hapless tourists… picked pockets… and to say at least thirty-six extremely rude things in Hungarian.” (all delivered as if it was a positive). Similarly a boy is said to have a “wicked sense of humor” as if that is a good attribute. We should mention there is a somewhat confusing part of the storyline for readers. All of a sudden Daisy is in a secret garden that turns out to be from some time way in the past with little to no explanation. Then the person she meets turns out to be a family member. It comes across as confusing for young readers. Daisy says she wants to visit “Shah Mosque in Isfahan” one day Daisy remarks that “It’s not eavesdropping if you just happen to be passing by”. Daisy says she wants to hit a girl she is frustrated with. Later when upset she says she was “going to kill her”. Someone says, “I thought he was dead. And I was glad’. The following terms are used: idiot, shut up. Someone disrespectfully says, “Your father’s a fool”
VerdictPrayerfully Consider
Our Thoughts
We have seen books like this before, where from a concerning content standpoint it just feels like death by… at least some number of cuts. As usual, all of this content just feel totally unnecessary. We would like to say there is a solid focus on the creation we are called to have dominion over, but that isn’t really the case from a Christian perspective as that aspect is off (see above). Esteeming the creation without the Creator is not something we want to show our children. There are good aspects. The story itself is pretty interesting and does get exciting as the book progresses. The book surprises with neat illustrations scattered throughout that are quite good. Daisy’s mom is a travelling journalist and this comes across as a really interesting profession (Daisy even travels with her, which is neat). Solid friendships are formed. We have this one as a Prayerfully Consider.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
*An Instant New York Times Bestseller* "If you don't believe in magic, you will after you've read Greenwild" - A. F. Steadman "An eco-thriller novel that every child should read" - The Telegraph The Secret Garden meets A Wrinkle in Time in Greenwild: The World Behind the Door, the first book in the most extraordinary new fantasy trilogy. Open the door to a spellbinding world where the wilderness is alive and a deep magic rises from the earth itself . . . Eleven-year-old Daisy Thistledown is on the run. Her mother has been keeping big, glittering secrets, and now she has vanished. Daisy knows it’s up to her to find Ma—but someone is hunting her across London. Someone determined to stop her from discovering the truth. So when Daisy flees to safety through a mysterious hidden doorway, she can barely believe her eyes—she has stepped out of the city and into another world. This is the Greenwild. Bursting with magic and full of amazing natural wonders, it seems too astonishing to be true. But not only is this land of green magic real, it holds the key to finding Daisy’s mother. And someone wants to destroy it. Daisy must band together with a botanical genius, a boy who can talk with animals, and a spunky cat to uncover the truth about who she really is. Only then can she channel the power that will change her whole world . . . and save the Greenwild itself.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
Your word is a lamp for my feet, a light on my path. I have taken an oath and confirmed it, that I will follow your righteous laws. I have suffered much; preserve my life, Lord, according to your word. Accept, Lord, the willing praise of my mouth, and teach me your laws. Though I constantly take my life in my hands, I will not forget your law. The wicked have set a snare for me, but I have not strayed from your precepts. Your statutes are my heritage forever; they are the joy of my heart. My heart is set on keeping your decrees to the very end.
— Psalm 119:105-112
More Christian Parent Reviews