Good Dogs on a Bad Day

VERDICT: Avoid

Concern Level: Medium-High

Book Cover for Good Dogs on a Bad Day

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

The main issue here is that the book attempts to focus on right & wrong, but misses wildly on the messaging that we Christians would want our children to understand and believe on this topic. As you read the samples below, keep in mind that while the book has a nice and happy ending, this behavior is never resolved and shown as wrong. Examples: One dog says about their potential bad behavior, “we can’t, we’re good dogs” to which another replies “and what good has that ever done us?” At another point a dog says that now he is misbehaving for a very good reason. There are frequent examples of them indulging in behavior they have been taught by their owners as wrong and each time it is shown as a total blast as well as totally freeing and natural (think of all of the examples of commercials and movies and the way they portray alcohol and immoral living). One dog asks if they are being bad dogs during a day when they are doing everything they have been taught not to and his friend answers no, they had just been doing what they had had to do which is then followed by describing themselves as not bad dogs, but good dogs having a bad day. In another instance one character says not to think of their theft as stealing, but rather to just think of it as helping. One of the dogs tells another that their owner says good dogs never steal people food to which the friend says, that well, she’s not here right now. To make things worse, there is a lot of justifying the behavior (e.g., saying if their owner had been paying attention to them that none of the bad behavior would have happened). At one point they decide that they had already done so much (bad behavior), why not just keep going the rest of the day? Similarly, the thought comes up that since they try so hard to be good that they should just have a wild day. Later in the book they decide that maybe it is more fun without anyone telling them what to do. There are several more examples, but you get the main gist of the issue that comes up throughout. — There are several irreverent instances of “Oh my dog!”. — There are a few other concerning moments to know about. At the start of the book a dog is describing his family in a very busy mode and says that the parents are barking at the kids and each other. One of the main dogs is shallow and obsessed with Instagram and her followers. She brings this up throughout the book as it is the lens she views the world from. She thinks that nothing is more important than attention. At the start a young girl tells her parents that if she doesn’t get a puppy her birthday will be ruined. A boy lies to cover for his dog and it is portrayed as a good thing. - A few other things that are mentioned to be aware of: Beyoncé (she is called “the Queen), coming back as a ghost, OMG, passing gas, pee, butt, barf.

Our Thoughts

The best way we can describe this book is a cute book about dogs intended to be focused on the topic of morality, originating from a confused world that has no solid moral compass. On the good side, it is light and a bit funny with cute illustrations all told through the eyes of a group of family dogs. It is a next step up from “graphic novels” in reading length and challenge, but not too difficult. It also has a sweet ending. But it is really hard to recommend putting this in front of a child with the core issue pointed out above. While we have not reviewed them yet, we would imagine that the other entries in this series that are not trying to tackle morality while seemingly being very unprepared to do are hopefully safer options that provide the good of this book without the pretty serious negative.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

The Secret Life of Pets meets Toy Story in a new illustrated series about a group of Very Good doggie day care buddies who follow a few of their wilder instincts, leading to hilarious chaos. Do good dogs have to be good all the time? Hugo, Lulu, and King love going to doggy day care together.

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Kirkus Reviews
Warnings

Providing this review as a reminder to Christian parents of why it is so important to be cautious of secular review sources.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Therefore, I urge you, brothers and sisters, in view of God's mercy, to offer your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God—this is your true and proper worship. Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Then you will be able to test and approve what God's will is—his good, pleasing and perfect will.

— Romans 12:1-2

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews

Christian Review of Ali Cross
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Red, White and Whole
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of Wingfeather Tales
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of FAKE
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Amulet: The Stonekeeper
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of When Sea Becomes Sky
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of The Dream Traveler's Quest - Into the Book of Light
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of The Beast and the Bethany
Concern Level: High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of The Hidden Hand
Concern Level: Medium

VERDICT
HIGHLY Recommended
Christian Review of Big Nate – In a Class by Himself
Concern Level: High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of The One and Only Ivan
Concern Level: Medium-Low

VERDICT
Prayerfully Consider
Christian Review of The Quiet Little Woman: a Christmas Story
Concern Level: Low

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Little Bear’s Friend
Concern Level: None

VERDICT
Recommended
Christian Review of Doodleville
Concern Level: Medium-High

VERDICT
Avoid
Christian Review of The Year My Life Went Down the Toilet
Concern Level: Extreme

VERDICT
Avoid