See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3
Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Author & Story

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Author & Story

Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After #1)

VERDICT: HIGHLY Recommended
 (with caution)

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for Fairest of Heart (Texas Ever After #1)

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

The most important thing to know about this one is that it is a wonderful overtly Christian book in a genre many parents are actively seeking. That being said, there is an aspect of the storyline that will make this particular title from this author one Christian parents will need to make sure they carefully consider for their particular older children (we do highly recommend this as one parents can equally enjoy – and certainly plan to review more from this author). This is the reason we set the Concern Level the way we did, not that there is content that shouldn’t be there, but just to get parents attention so they can carefully consider. Here we will lay out everything that Christian parents need to know, but we do ask that you also read the next section to get the full picture for this excellent book.

In faithful Christian books, the content that parents most have to wrestle with is typically found in a mature Christian author who sets out to accurately represent evil within the villain character(s). That is certainly the case here. Nearly everything we will lay forward for you to consider here has to do with the picture of evil laid forth in the villainous Madame LaBelle (aka Narcissa). But Narcissa’s evil comes in a different form than most villains your children will be familiar with, and that is where parental consideration focuses.

In this fascinating and very unique fairy tale retelling (see below) Narcissa represents a secretly wicked woman obsessed with her appearance. And in this tale that takes the form of deceiving men out of their valuables in her work to earn enough money to eventually trick and marry a very wealthy man and live in luxury. How does she do this? This Christian author is very cautious and intentional with it, but at the end of the day Narcissa employs seduction. She is also extremely manipulative. It is important to note that all of her actions are shown as very wicked, which is a really important point for Christians. Here are some details to help you gauge this:

  • A man Narcissa is targeting is said to have a “lustful gleam in his eyes”.
  • When looking in a mirror she makes a “seductive pout” face
  • Narcissa admires herself by “tugging down the neckline of her bodice slightly, she eyed her abundant curves swelling above the snug fabric. Still her best feature”.
  • She refers to her bosom as “her assets”
  • Narcissa manipulates a man named Hunt into doing her dirty work through seductive affection and lies.
  • Another Narcissa is said to have a “hungry look in his eyes” and his “gaze dipped to her chest and lingered. Exactly as she’d designed”. This time we see her wicked deception take place. She chooses to leave with a man to be alone, but tells that she drugs him with laudanum, saying he “won’t know what hit him” and along with the wine “she’d endure his overtures with an acting skill that would convince him he was the greatest lover she’d ever known then he’d tumble into bed unconscious” before she robbed him.
  • She thinks how “her dress fit her like a second skin, showing off every curve, of which there were many – all in the right place”.
  • When tricking another man she “nibbles on his earlobe” and “led him towards the bed, commenting, ‘We obviously need to give you a lesson in ladies corsets… I suggest we start with the one I’m wearing”.

Penelope and Titus (the other main characters) are the opposite of Narcissa (more below) and a wonderful duo of characters. There are a f

While mostly mild, there is a bit of intensity that flares up at times that Christian parents should know about:

  • Narcissa is a sociopath in a way many Christian readers won’t be familiar with. She is so manipulative. While, again, it is handled very well, for some it may be a bit jarring.
  • Narcissa threatens, “I’ll shred you to ribbons”.
  • Eventually Narcissa asks Hunt to dispose of Penelope. He physically grabs her, bounds and gags her while Pen tries to escape, but can’t.
  • When feeling righteous anger Titus considers strangling someone.
  • When considering a what-if, we read, “He could have strangled her or slit her throat while she was sleeping”. This is after a potentially frightening scene where someone sneaks into Penelope’s room while she is sleeping before being scared off.
  • Narcissa tells Pen she will kill her friends while they are sleeping by suffocating them with a pillow.
  • Again later when extremely frustrated Titus thinks how he wants to “tear Narcissa’s cold, unfeeling heart out of her chest”.

Other items to be aware of:

  • Someone mentions a fortune teller in passing
  • There is one mention of “luck” when a blessing is given.
  • A sinful man references “curves that would tempt a saint”. He also says, “I can’t imagine tying myself to one woman… where’s the fun in that?... Variety is the spice of life”. He then testifies that “I took the lady to dinner and back at my quarters for a bottle of wine and a little… entertainment. Getting ready for bed that evening was a bit… shall we say… haphazard”.
Our Thoughts

One of the more recent books we reviewed was a secular title loaded with inappropriate content in an attempt at humor. This Christian love story has quite a bit to consider when deciding on it for your older, more mature children, but it is a totally different case. Here we have a bit more mature plot elements woven in, but woven into an entertaining, faith-building story. Older teens and young adults that are mature enough for it will be both entertained and enriched spiritually from this title.

There is so much to like here from a Christian perspective. We will share some of our favorite things:

  • The two main characters Penelope (aka Pen) and Titus are just awesome. These are the type characters that Christian parents really desire to see in the books they read themselves and provide to their children. They aren’t just “nice”... they are consistently good and focused on holiness and godliness throughout.
  • Scripture and biblical references are woven in throughout, such as when Pen likens her situation to that of Joseph when he was sold by his brothers into slavery. All within the first dozen pages a Psalm is referenced a hymn is sung, laying the foundation for the content to come.
  • Similarly, normal Christian dialogue comes through as well, like when Titus refers to animals as “God’s creatures”, telling someone, “I think the Good Lord might disagree” when someone indicates one of these creatures doesn’t matter. Later Pen mentions having “a Father who would never leave or forsake her”.
  • The dedication is to a couple, where the author says, “May the Lord bless you with a love so true that it can withstand any obstacle and keep you smiling as you walk hand in hand through happily ever after”
  • A verse sets the frame with a verse - Jn 16:33 “In this world you will have tribulation, but be of good cheer; I have overcome the world”
  • Very early in the story, Pen is told by a very loving maternal figure that “The Lord has provided a fresh start”. This woman truly shows the difference we can make in someone’s life. After taking her in when she was abandoned at her work,, this woman taught her about the Lord Jesus, sang hymns to her, and more. We see clearly that this is the driving force behind who Penelope grew to be. We see less of it, but Titus was also heavily influenced spiritually by his late grandmother. We again hear of her singing hymns.
  • We discover that Pen was abandoned as a baby, but was taught to “pray to a God who loved all His children”
  • In a wonderful line, Titus says of Pen she was “smiling with a purity so rare it had momentarily stolen his wits”.
  • The power of faith lessons being integrated into a fictional story is very real. Later we also read Titus saying, “Either the Good Lord wanted him to be a Ranger, or he didn’t… Seemed he was about to find out which path the Good Lord mapped out for him“.
  • Prayer is heavily emphasized all the way through, like when Penelope “poured out her heart to the God who had kept her safe.
  • Modesty is a real focus, and is very refreshing in today’s culture.

We will stop there, but honestly this list could be several times long.

From an entertainment perspective, this book scores really high marks. Parents will have experienced many retellings of fairy tales. Over our years of reviewing we have encountered more than than our fair share. This is hands down our favorite one. We genuinely enjoyed the "Chicago, Illinois Spring 1892” western setting for our fairy tale adoption. Seeing the way the author wove in elements like the dwarfs into this setting was so enjoyable.

It is important that Christian parents carefully consider works like this for their individual child (older teen or young adult), but when ready we do highly recommend this title. The book ends with both Penelope and Titus separately giving ultimate glory and honor to God. This is an author we will certainly review more books as we continue to bring Christian parents more faith-building alternatives. Enjoy.

Plot Summary

Note: This information is typically from the publisher.

2024 Holt Medallion Finalist

2024 Golden Scroll Award Finalist

Beauty has been nothing but a curse to Penelope Snow. When she becomes a personal maid for a famous actress whose troupe is leaving Chicago to tour the west, she hides her figure beneath shapeless dresses and keeps her head down. But she still manages to attract the wrong attention, leaving her prospects in tatters—and her jealous mistress plotting her demise.

After his brother lost his life over a woman, Texas Ranger Titus Kingsley has learned to expect the worst from females and is rarely disappointed. So when a young woman found in suspicious circumstances takes up residence with the seven old drovers living at his grandfather’s ranch, Titus is determined to keep a close eye on her.

With a promotion hanging in the balance, Titus investigates a robbery case tied to Penelope’s old acting troupe. The evidence points to her guilt, but Titus’s heart divines a different truth—one that might just get Penelope killed.

An enchanting Western take on the classic Snow White fairy tale, Fairest of Heart will sweep you away from once upon a time to happily ever after.

Praise for Fairest of Heart:

“Witemeyer proves once again that fairytales are not just for kids. [A] whimsical historical romance.”

  • The Stand

“An intriguing historical romance! . . . Plenty of character development, moments of suspense, good themes, and a little humor . . . an entertaining read that I’d recommend to those who enjoy Christian fiction, historical romances, and fairy tale retellings.”

  • Interviews and Reviews

“An excellent start to [Witemeyer's] Texas Ever After series. This creative take on the Snow White fairy tale will delight her fans. . . I loved this story from beginning to end and applaud the author for her ingenuity. I can't wait for the next one!”

  • Interviews and Reviews
Purchase Link

Above Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.

Purchase Book Convenience Link

Scripture Reflection

For the grace of God has appeared that offers salvation to all people. It teaches us to say 'No' to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, while we wait for the blessed hope—the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.

— Titus 2:11-14