See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

Crumble (A Graphic Novel)

VERDICT: Avoid

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for Crumble (A Graphic Novel)

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

As we often find in graphic novels, much of the content doesn’t line up with the cute and colorful content. In this book the beloved Aunt character dies in a car wreck. The young reader sees an illustration of her car post-accident. The main character is called to the school office. We see her devastated before the book cuts to a funeral wake scene. Much of the rest of the book deals with the ensuing borderline depression of the main children characters and mom. Surprisingly at the end this (again light-looking graphic novel) book sends children to websites and phone numbers (including one you can text) instead of their parents for dealing with difficult times like this. The book opens in a pretty confusing way, with a customer at a bake shop being asked “What kind of feeling are you looking for today?” We find this family can bake feelings into bakery goods and the book speaks about this as if it is totally normal. If you feel uneasy about that, it gets quite a bit more dicey later when negative feelings (due to the tragedy above) end up getting transferred from the depressed main character to the eaters, who get very sick (leaving her lethargic and unfeeling for a time, which becomes addictive to her). Again, remember this is a short, colorful graphic novel that will attract many young readers. On hearing about a bird laying an egg, the main character comments that she thought the bird was a male. The best friend replies, “Gender non conformists. We’re everywhere”. We learn this friend has “two dads” (“But then my other Dad said…”). Then at the very end, even though there was no mention in the story itself, that this character who is clearly female is “non-binary”. The illustrator shares that they “really wanted their outfits and style to reflect their gender expression”. The main character’s mother is sadly not really much of a part of her life. The book portrays this as not really a big deal: “Don’t you miss your mom when she’s gone?” gets the reply “No. It’s always been like this. And I get to talk to her at night (on the phone). And Aunt Gina is always here”. Friends cover for each other when doing wrong. The following statement is made: “This totally proves Cthulhu is real” The term jerk is used

Our Thoughts

While there are certainly nice things we can say about this book (included recipes, a nice dynamic between certain characters, etc.), there is just too much stacked up against it. Given everything above, we have this one as an Avoid for Christian families.

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

A heartfelt and magic-filled graphic novel for fans of Sheets and Real Friends about baking, friendship, and feeling every kind of emotion—no matter the flavor. Emily, her mom, and her aunt Gina have a very special magical power: They can bake emotions into the desserts they sell at their family bakery. Need a dash of confidence? Try their millionaire shortbread! Want relief after a stressful day? The cheesecake will lighten your spirits! There is only one rule: Never bake a bad feeling.    Every day after school, Emily and her best friend, Dae, make tried-and-true recipes, while she and Aunt Gina brainstorm new ones. But when Aunt Gina dies in an accident, Emily’s life is turned upside down. Not knowing what to do, Emily breaks the rule and bakes her bad feelings into. . . a crumble. It looks gross. Dae says it tastes gross. But they can’t stop eating it. Neither can Emily’s classmates. And with her grief and pain baked into the crumble, Emily gets the comfort of being at least a little numb. So even though she’s not supposed to, she makes it again, and again, and again.  But baking (and eating) bad feelings doesn’t really make them go away . . .  Praise for Crumble "Deliciously cute, funny, and touching." —Kirkus Reviews, starred review "Equal parts love and heartbreak.... Unique and poignant." —BookPage, starred review

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Kirkus Reviews
Warnings

Including this “review” as a huge reminder on why Christian’s need Christian review sources. Calling this. Read everything we have above and see if you think “Deliciously cute” is fitting.

Read Review
Secular Review (use with Caution!)
School Library Journal
Our Thoughts on this Review

Unlike the other review we included this one at least helps to give a bit of the feel of the book.

Warnings

Even with this content, this review should send the same message to Christian parents, rely on detailed Christian review sources for content for your children.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world. This is how you can recognize the Spirit of God: Every spirit that acknowledges that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God, but every spirit that does not acknowledge Jesus is not from God.

— 1 John 4:1-3

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews