Concern Level: Medium
Note that this series holds a special place in the hearts of many Christians who read this when they were young and are now Christian parents today. ... → Continue reading below
Christian Author & Story
Christy Miller - Summer Promise
VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider
Concern Level: Medium

Concern LevelMedium
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
Note that this series holds a special place in the hearts of many Christians who read this when they were young and are now Christian parents today. Our goal here is to take a fresh and honest look at this first title, keeping future first-time youth readers in mind. The most important thing for Christian parents is that this book should only be considered only for older, more mature teens and young adults. This first book is a story that ends in salvation, but for 99% of the book Christy is unsaved. We see life through her eyes and she is worldly and honestly borderline obsessed with boys, being pretty/liked, and is often jealous of other girls. While this is all too often an accurate picture of someone untouched by Christ’s love and redemption, it does put a lot of focus for a long time on un-Christlike things. There are people in the opening credits who shared encouragement with the author about being moved by these books, and we have no doubt that is true, but it is important to know what is here so you can determine if this is a good fit for your kiddo. We will try and catalog this so you understand the road this book takes on the way to redemption. We should also say that we are only reviewing this book. We would expect and hope that future books, after her giving her life to Jesus, have much more to offer in faith-building material. While we fully expect this Focus on the Family published book series gets better, we just wish more of it was in this first title. Make sure to read the next section of this review below too, as it is important to have the full picture. This is also a very important book to read the other reviews on below, as several we found provide a lot of content around the larger series. Christy is 14 years old and we read life through her eyes. She spends much of the book obsessing over boys, eventually locking in on one she desperately wants to date. It is a constant throughout. Unfortunately, the book doesn’t really resolve this nearly as much as we would have liked (e.g., having her start to realize her sufficiency in Christ and not needing to focus so much on dating). She is jealous of those around her who she views as prettier and better with boys than she is. This is especially unfortunate in her treatment of one of the great Christian characters who she believes may be dating the boy she likes. Internally Christy is jealous and ugly to her, eventually spilling out into her actions towards her. Early in the story Christy ends up at a party. Even though she is unsaved she is out of her element in this environment. We soon see a lot of drinking and smoking. She eventually ends up upstairs looking for one of the only people she knows. Christy walks in on a group smoking marijuana. She really wants something to drink so she begins talking about Coke, which gets confused with the drug. She also mentions she tried beer at age 10 at her friend’s house and didn’t like it. There are a couple of more mature parts of the book. In a heavy moment, one of the kids who was using drugs at the party dies while high. There is quite a bit of focus on this. Later the girl Christy idolizes (who earlier we see clearly implied she is leaving to sleep with a guy she just met) breaks down and tells her that she is miserable. Her mom is a major alcoholic and has hit her. An older guy who Christy just thought of as “hot” comes over and, not realizing Christy is there, tries to push for sex. Then, seeing Christy he turns extremely rude and ugly. This girl also admits to trying to take her own life recently. This part ends with her saying, “You just don’t realize how good you have it. Stay innocent Christy, stay innocent”. Other things to be aware of: The book opens with Christy looking at her reflection saying, “I hate you! I hate you!”. Christy has a frightening dream where she is being pulled under the water by something and can’t escape (meant to be symbolic). Despite being described as a family that always went to church, there is a strained relationship with her Dad, who she feels never listens (hopefully this is setting up for reconciliation in future books). Christy makes a few comments about hating the beach environment and that she thinks everyone there is stuck up In one scene, surprisingly late in the book, Christy gets mad at her aunt and begins doing anything and everything she can to displease her and rebel.
VerdictPrayerfully Consider
Our Thoughts
We don’t list many Christian books as “Prayerfully Consider”, but the main concern above is one we wanted to make sure that Christian parents stop and consider. We have only reviewed this first title, so we are hoping that the future books in the series focus more on a Christy being formed in Christ’s image and less uber-focused on guys. This one ends in salvation… and there is a LOT to be said for that. It also uses side characters to shine a bright light on the difference in living for Christ and living for self and this world. But as Christian parents we have to consider the full picture. We would encourage you to allow your older, more mature child to read this if you are willing to walk along the journey and discuss it with them, especially for a child who is likely interested in reading on later in the series. This is one for you to Prayerfully Consider. Some of the positives to be aware of… There is a clear distinction shown between the handful of Christians in this book and their way of life. The main distinctions are shown between the party life of the teenagers on the beach and the life of her rich and worldly aunt and uncle. There are a few solid Christians shown. Two teenagers, a young man and woman, were saved the summer before. Since then, their life has been radically different. At one point these two provide Christy with a Bible as a gift. The young woman, Tracy, is so graceful, calm, kind and unphased by the worries of life that it really sticks out to Christy. Todd mentions he specifically doesn’t participate in drinking and smoking because becoming a Christian and being baptized changed everything. At the funeral for the young man Todd shares verses about salvation. There are a couple neat scenes where a group of these believers are together. One is a concert that turns out to be a show at their church. The lead singer is an awesome Christian with really gospel focused lyrics. She senses that Christy is not right with God and instead just resting on religion and attempts to reach out to her. She is one of a few characters who try to get through to Christy in this way, often using neat examples. There is also a solid light shown on religion and growing up around Christianity not being enough. This is such an important message. Finally, Christy hits the desperation point. She realizes she has begun “talking to God as if it were the most natural thing for her today. She finally asks, “What am I doing wrong God?”. She finally gives her life to Jesus as Lord and Savior. This culminates with her in a group of believers on the beach around a fire singing worship and celebrating her decision. We read that “Christy has never felt her heart so full”. She is challenged to go back to her home and be more like this group to her friends and family. This story ends with a direct challenge to her aunt and uncle's very popular secular worldviews.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
As 14-year old Christy leaves her family's Wisconsin farm to spend the summer at her wealthy aunt and uncle's beach home in Newport, she realizes this could be the best season of her life. . Through it all, will Christy keep her promise to her parents not to do anything she'll regret?
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
This is a very helpful review that focuses on the collection of the first three books with comments on the series as a whole. It also has some excellent background on the author.
Very high-level view mentions, but does not detail potentially concerning content to be aware of.
Read ReviewThis is another great resource that focuses on the first 3 books. Great info! There is a bit of back and forth with parents at the bottom that may be worth reading for context as well (just be cautious). Really like the “by age group” breakdown.
Read ReviewPretty solid review from Plugged In for the first book
Read ReviewGreat set of discussion questions to use!
This attempt to summarize 3 books majorly misses the mark with being able to accurately portray the potentially concerning content to Christian parents.
Read ReviewA very positive review from someone who has read the series
Very light on potentially concerning content.
Read ReviewThe fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge, but fools despise wisdom and instruction. Listen, my son, to your father's instruction and do not forsake your mother's teaching. They are a garland to grace your head and a chain to adorn your neck.
— Proverbs 1:7-9
More Christian Parent Reviews