Concern Level: Extreme
There is so, so much to be concerned about here. First and foremost, while Christians are certainly called to love all people it does not mean we sac... → Continue reading below
Better Nate than Ever
VERDICT: Avoid
Concern Level: Extreme

Concern LevelExtreme
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
There is so, so much to be concerned about here. First and foremost, while Christians are certainly called to love all people it does not mean we sacrifice 'telling the truth, in love', no matter how unpopular it is. This book is clearly aimed at a promoting a view of homosexuality that, while militantly advanced in our current culture, is counter to the orthodox, traditional, conservative, biblical Christian view of God's intent for His world. On top of that, here is a small sample of the content collected from multiple reviewers that shows this book to be inappropriate for any age: There is foul language and 'underage drinking'. Nate is referred to with 8-10 instances of 'f-g, and it's variations, SuperF-g, f--got, and F-gster, and insults like homo, fairy, Gays and Dolls, and Natey the Lady'. Nate 'walks past a gay bar and sees men kissing inside, there are references to a stripper pole, drinking, and other adult topics... There's a very obvious coming out scene to his best friend'. Mom is also an alcoholic. His best friend 'sneaks a look into Anthony's underwear drawer and makes him flex, shirtless. There are fleeting references to a father's affair with an exotic dancer, strippers, pole dancing, a woman in a catsuit with leather b--bs, and the Museum of Sex. A male porno mag found in a student's locker is mentioned.' There are also many instances of God's name taken in vain and similar items. The core of this story also revolves around Nate lying, running away, stealing his brother's fake id and stealing his mom's ATM card.
VerdictAvoid
Our Thoughts
This is a coming-of-age story of a gay young man with a plot revolves around lying, stealing, deception and running away, with a large dose of inappropriate adult/sexual content thrown in for good measure. Sadly, Disney using this title to make a movie adaptation of to further promote their cultural agendas is only going to drive more children to this book, which goes much farther than even the already concerning film version. Parents who feel ready to discuss the mature topic of homosexuality and God's original intent for people/family/sexuality with their children can certainly to find a much better (and cleaner) resource to do so. As N.T. Wright said in his commentary on 1 Thessalonians, ‘our modern world has turned sexual desire, preference and practice into a moral free-for-all’. This is not the worldview we are called to. We Christians are called to a life of holiness, dedicated to God and His design for His good world. Our books should reflect that.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
Nate Foster has big dreams. His whole life, he's wanted to star in a Broadway show. (Heck, he'd settle for seeing a Broadway show.) But how is Nate supposed to make his dreams come true when he's stuck in Jankburg, Pennsylvania, where no one (except his best pal Libby) appreciates a good show tune? With Libby's help, Nate plans a daring overnight escape to New York. There's an open casting call for E.T.: The Musical, and Nate knows this could be the difference between small-town blues and big-time stardom. Tim Federle's 'hilarious and heartwarming debut novel' (Publishers Weekly) is full of broken curfews, second chances, and the adventure of growing up—because sometimes you have to get four hundred miles from your backyard to finally feel at home.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books
We don't say this lightly... but this is one review CSM should be ashamed of having put in front of the trusting parents who use thier site. This is a good example of why you need to use so much caution with Common Sense Media. CSM can at times provide helpful insight into concerning content, but they often promote a liberal secular worldview that Christians should be very cautious of. Go no further than the concerning content in the parent and (sadly) even kid reviews and notice none of it is called out. They (astonishingly) recommend this to kids 10+ along with giving it multiple awards for 'positive message' and 'positive worldview'. Also, a 2 of 5 for 'Sex, Romance and Nudity' is misleading to say the least due to the many adult references.
Read ReviewThis link shows the 2-star reviews from Amazon. They show how concerning the book is, even without taking the Christian worldview into account.
Keep in mind these concerns are underexagerated considering they don't even address the Christian worldview concerns. Always be cautious of putting too much weight into reviews posted on sites like this.
Read ReviewThis link shows the 1-star reviews from Amazon. They show how concerning the book is, even without taking the Christian worldview into account.
Keep in mind these concerns are underexagerated considering they don't even address the Christian worldview concerns. Always be cautious of putting too much weight into reviews posted on sites like this.
Read ReviewSo I say, walk by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh. For the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. They are in conflict with each other, so that you are not to do whatever you want. But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under the law.
— Galatians 5:16-18
More Christian Parent Reviews