See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3
Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Author & Story

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Author & Story

Beneath the Swirling Sky (the Restorationists)

VERDICT: HIGHLY Recommended
 (with caution)

Concern Level: Medium-Low

Book Cover for Beneath the Swirling Sky (the Restorationists)

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

This is a mostly clean book, but there are a few things to be aware of. Here are the items to consider for your young reader:

While the two main girl characters are solid, tor most of the book Vincent isn’t the greatest person. This sets up a big transformation for him, but good to know it is there. We read things like him saying Georgia (the other main character) looks weird and “like a homeless person” upon meeting her. He rolls his eyes, complains, is negative, etc. The book includes a sad comment indicating that Vincent’s family only “went to church a few times a year” (important that our kids know it is great to experience God in art and nature, but Christians are called to be together in church!). Note that all of this is before the encounter with Jesus we share below.

In a more serious than the rest of the content moment, Vincent recalls his grandparents home burning down “killing them and his mom’s sister”. A big part of the plot revolves around Lili, Vincent’s younger sister actually being kidnapped by a bad group (certainly handled with the audience in mind, but may frighten some). The most intense comment from this comes when we hear about this group, “About ten years ago the Distortionists massacred most of the Restorationists families”. We are told “If you die in a painting, you die”. One of the paintings they go into has a creepy drawn guy in it they have to avoid and he is shown in one of the few illustrations in the book.

Vincent tries to eavesdrop on parent conversations

Georgia lightly jokingly says, “That’s because this is where the boogy man lives! If you don’t do as you’re told, you’ll vanish”.

Vincent mentions wanting to have a video game marathon

The main characters sneak around the uncle’s house, often late at night, even picking locks and such. This escalates as the adventure goes on.

There is a random mention of zombies (“The only Zombies I want to see are in Minecraft”)

One of the paintings Vincent enters “was full of naked people”. He says, “It’s gross” to which Georgia replies, “Naked people are a part of art. You get used to it. But maybe it’s not a good thing.” (note the kids cover their heads while travelling through here. Discussed a bit in the author’s note.

Someone refers to a quest as a “suicide mission”

Towards the end Uncle Leo and the 3 kids make up a lie to tell the FBI. Here we read, “If she had trouble believing that, she’d never buy the actual truth”, adding “Uncle Leo coached them on the story”.

Our Thoughts

Sometimes a book surprises you in a good way. This was one of those books for us. One of the core pillars of our mission is seeking out Christian stories and putting them front and center so Christian parents have better alternatives available. We had seen a few indications that this was a Christian story, but pretty far into it with very little evidence pointing in that direction we were starting to seriously think this wasn’t the case and that, at best a “clean” book from an author who professed Christianity. And then the moment hit. A central portion of the plot for this book revolves around members of a family being able to enter into paintings. Pretty cool. But the big moment comes late in the book when the main character Vincent finds himself inside of a famous painting of Jesus on the boat with his disciples in the middle of a storm. The scene is alive and Vincent, on another craft, thinks he is about to perish. It is here that he has a real encounter with the Lord Jesus that changes everything for him. It’s beautiful.

This moment alone is worth having your child read this engaging story, no question, but here are a few more things we appreciated in this one:

Two great quotes start the book, the best of which is a gospel focused quote from… Van Gogh. Did you expect that? Later readers are told Van Gogh felt closer to God through nature, to which a character says, “for me, it’s art.

One sweet part of the earlier portion of the book, a flashback discusses Vincent going to China for two weeks to pick up their newly adopted daughter Lili. Lili grabs Vincent’s finger and wouldn’t let go and they have been close ever since. A really refreshing positive sibling relationship in a book!

There is a really great emphasis on artwork and appreciating it. Many famous authors and paintings are intertwined. Even the work or art restoration is put on display. Example: “Art expresses beauty and truth. It’s a gift. It’s meant to be experienced”.

Also nice, Georgia is a confident and intelligent homeschooler.

One of the children comments, “Of course I’m scared, but fear shouldn’t get to decide what I do”.

The author’s note ends the book by telling young readers “The urge to create is one way we exhibit the image of God”

There is a bit of content to consider in the section above, but overall this is a Christian title we HIGHLY Recommended.

Plot Summary

Note: This information is typically from the publisher.

A house full of paintings, a missing sister, and a family secret send a boy and his cousin into a world where art is the key in this fantasy adventure perfect for fans of The Wingfeather Saga and Pages & Co.

“A delightful adventure, excellent for reading aloud. This book will make you want to study Van Gogh and get out the paintbrushes!”—Sarah Mackenzie, founder and host of Read-Aloud Revival® and author of The Read-Aloud Family

After an experience he’d rather forget, Vincent is determined to be done with art. So when he and his little sister, Lili, spend spring break with their art conservator great-uncle, Vincent's plan is to stay glued to his phone.

That is, until Lili disappears into one of the world's most famous paintings and Vincent learns his parents have been hiding something from Their family is the last of The Restorationists, a secret society with the power to travel through paintings—and a duty to protect them from evil forces.

With Lili’s safety on the line, leaving art behind is no longer an option. Vincent must team up with his know-it-all second-cousin Georgia, wrestle with why his parents lied to him, and confront both his past and a future he never wanted. Young readers are invited into a captivating universe where paintings become a portal—and adventure and danger lurk beyond every canvas.

Purchase Link

Above Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.

Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Christian Review
Young Llama Reader
Our Thoughts on this Review

Neat review from a young Christian reviewer!

Warnings

Summarizes potential concerns, but not a detailed listing of potentially concerning content.

Read Review
Christian Review
Blossoming Through Books
Our Thoughts on this Review

Nice review worth reading through.

Warnings

Not a detailed potentially concerning content review.

Read Review
Christian Review
Christianbook (parent reviews)
Warnings

While often helpful, be cautious with reviews on sites where anyone can post.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moths and vermin destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moths and vermin do not destroy, and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also. The eye is the lamp of the body. If your eyes are healthy, your whole body will be full of light.

— Matthew 6:19-21