See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

Apple Crush: (A Graphic Novel)

VERDICT: Avoid

Concern Level: Medium-High

Book Cover for Apple Crush: (A Graphic Novel)

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

Note: Some of the concerning content, such as advertising non-children’s graphic novels from the author in a children’s book are repeated here. Please read our review of the original book (Stepping Stones) as well to get the full picture. This sequel expands upon a relationship that worried us from the first graphic novel. In the first, the neighbors, two male farmers, are shown standing a little too close and interacting in a way that is not natural. As we expected (and feared) this is expanded upon in the sequels. There is no more hinting, this is basically confirmed to be a gay relationship between these two men. The illustrations show the hand of one of the men on the back of the other, then affectionately holding his arm, then arm around each other. From a Christian perspective, these pictures show just how completely unnatural this is. On that note, the nephew character calls these men “my uncles”. A new set of concerning content is introduced here. This book happens in the fall time and the author uses this setting to introduce a lot of darker content. From a secular standpoint, many won’t see this as a big deal, but for Christians we are not called to celebrate darkness alongside the culture. Early in the book Jen draws a ghost, witch and other evil things. The term “spooky” is used in a very positive light. We hear of a “haunted hayride” which features zombies, witches, characters with very creepy masks. One character says, “bats, ghosts and zombies. It’s gonna be awesome”. There are drawings of these types of things throughout. The main characters eventually participate in this creepy event, with Jen dressing as a zombie. There is a lot of this. There is also a significant ramp up in the amount of dating/crush related content. Two kids hug when alone. This eventually becomes multiple scenes of romantic kissing. The worst of this comes when Jen walks in on her mom and boyfriend (who she has moved in with) romantically embracing and kissing in their room when they think no one is home (remember the inevitable young audience of these graphic novels).

Our Thoughts

We often only review the first book in a series, allowing us to cover a wider breadth of content. For this one we decided to review the full series. This is because a) we had a feeling that the a concerning relationship would be further expanded once kids were hooked on the story (it did) and b) because these are exactly the type of books with super colorful and engaging covers that draw young kids attention at the library or bookstore. On the positive side, this book has a much less negative feel than the first. Unfortunately, this is easily offset by a new set of concerning content (the spooky/evil focus) and a ramp up of both romantic content and something that was hinted at in the first book (the gay relationship portrayed between the neighboring farmers). Unfortunately, this sequel is also one we have as an Avoid for Christian families. A few other items to share: Jen’s mom tells her that she and her dad “really tried”, but “marriages are complicated” (certainly not a Christian message on marriage) Jen lies to her dad about doing her homework When visiting her dad, Jen leaves his apartment when he is sleeping. She draws in class despite not being allowed to The term “wicked” is used in place of “cool” Jen’s mom refers to her as a “late bloomer” Jen’s stepdad says 6th grade is “romance central”

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

In the second book of a bestselling graphic novel series that explores family, friendship, and change, a former city kid is finally adjusting to life on a farm with two brand-new stepsisters when she faces an even bigger challenge: middle school. “Readers looking for budding romance (or avoiding it altogether) will find characters to cheer.” —School Library Journal, starred review Jen is just getting used to her life on Peapod Farm with her new stepsisters, Andy and Reese. But when the school year starts, there are even more changes in store for her. Jen has to navigate new friends and new challenges—but at least she’ll have Andy with her, right? As she starts sixth grade, she finds that her stepsister seems way more interested in crushes and boys than hanging out with her, while Jen wants to know when the world decided boys and girls couldn’t be “just friends” anymore. Look for the whole Peapod Farm series STEPPING STONES • APPLE CRUSH • SUGAR SHACK

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books

Scripture Reflection

Search me, God, and know my heart; test me and know my anxious thoughts. See if there is any offensive way in me, and lead me in the way everlasting. You have searched me, Lord, and you know me. You know when I sit and when I rise; you perceive my thoughts from afar.

— Psalm 139:23-24

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews