Concern Level: Medium-High
‘Magicians’ are a main focus of this story, but that word may be misleading. The way to think about these characters are regular, everyday feeling, p... → Continue reading below
Amari and the Night Brothers
VERDICT: Avoid
Concern Level: Medium-High

Concern LevelMedium-High
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
‘Magicians’ are a main focus of this story, but that word may be misleading. The way to think about these characters are regular, everyday feeling, people who practice magic… which brings us to the real consideration for Christians. How does this line up with the at least closely related practices we are told as Christians to stay away from in the Bible? Is it different when a ‘good’ character uses ‘magic’ to battle evil? Or are we just tiptoeing along a line further and further away from the holiness (call to be set apart) God calls us to? This has been a challenging question for Christians for a long time, especially when it comes to ‘entertainment’. We think reading everything below all at once, instead of sprinkled throughout an engaging story will make it clear how we should feel about this one. And just to be clear… this ‘magical’ content is pervasive, coming up page after page after page (often referred to here as ‘supernatural’). This is not Disney princess whimsical magic. We read of magic, enchantments, spell books and curses. The revealed world is filled with things like werewolves, weredragons, witches, boogeyman, ‘stepmother’ haunting, math gods and more. One side character is said to be a medium (communicates with the dead). There is a comment about a haunted house. Someone tells Amari to “remember, your magic is alive… It can sense your doubt”. There are several mentions of reading Amari’s ‘aura’. A crystal ball plays a major part in the storyline, but it is less about viewing the future, but rather a different, but similar magical use. A spell is said to be able to bring back the dead (involves draining life from the living). Amari herself (the hero) casts spells, one of which shows her rival her worst nightmare. In one part of the book we see this blurring of good and evil really come into focus. Amari visits the “Department of Good Fortunes and Bad Omens”. During this visit we hear of crystal balls, tarot cards, ‘readings’, and fortune tellers. Near this point we also see her and her friends visit an “All Souls Festival” where ghosts appear and mingle with the living. We want to make sure to point out that there is one reference that is far out of measure with the rest in its “darkness”. The evil magician characters are described as having figured out how to prolong their lives like vampires by “consuming the blood of the innocents”. This is never shown in detail, but is mentioned a few times and, at one point, we see one of these characters drinking from a cup and are told blood is trickling down his face. Again, nothing else that is surface-level as dark-feeling as this, but it is a really important one to know about. Aside from that main potential concerning content category, there is a bit more to be aware of. The story opens with Amari in the principal's office, as she has shoved a girl who “got in her face”. While the other girls are clearly shown to be the instigators and ‘in the wrong’ there is much to be desired with our main character’s responses. She calls the main perpetrator “stuck up little Mrs. Princess”. Amari and her brother live with her mother. We find that her dad left them. She recalls her father as a drunk and describes a time when she overheard him say, “She probably isn’t even mine. Tell whoever her real daddy is to get her that stupid bike”. We read that Amari and her brother used to sneak up to the roof all the time despite not being allowed. She justifies it with a really disappointing comment, “like we didn’t have enough sense to stay away from the edge”. On a similar line, Amari sneaks out of her house when she is not allowed, and this is not shown in a negative light. Amari’s brother, who is held in a super-positive light, is said to have “rap posters” and a signed picture of Steven Hawking in his room. A cigar collection is referenced. A magazine is titled, “Deadbook: A Ghoulish Fashion Guide” A wicked girl in a waking dream dissolves when sunlight hits her. An old memory is brought up of one of the evil characters having a stake driven into their heart by a ‘good’ character in the past. The following references are all present: devilish charm, sucks, ‘pretty dope for a cavewoman’
VerdictAvoid
Our Thoughts
Wow, this one was an interesting one to review. The best parallel we can think of for Christian parents to understand this story/series is the Harry Potter series (although of course, there are differences as well). We would even venture to say that your feelings on this book will likely line up directly with how you feel about that series. Both are stories of good versus evil, but along the way there are several ways that Christians will see the lines being unfortunately blurred. This is an exciting, unique and incredibly imaginative story. It brings a fascinating world that mirrors ours, but introduces a whole new behind the scenes world that unveils itself to Amari, the main character. This one is one of those rare finds that will appeal to so many… but… with all that being said, like Harry Potter, this incredibly engaging story comes with a lot of baggage that a large portion of Christians will wish had been left out, as detailed above. We went back and forth on this one, and honestly we hate to do it for such an entertaining story, but we decided to list it as an Avoid. There is just too much blurring of good and evil for Christians to feel comfortable with themselves, let alone for their children.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
New York Times bestseller! Artemis Fowl meets Men in Black in this exhilarating debut middle grade fantasy, the first in a trilogy filled with #blackgirlmagic. Perfect for fans of Tristan Strong Punches a Hole in the Sky, the Percy Jackson series, and Nevermoor. Amari Peters has never stopped believing her missing brother, Quinton, is alive. Not even when the police told her otherwise, or when she got in trouble for standing up to bullies who said he was gone for good. So when she finds a ticking briefcase in his closet, containing a nomination for a summer tryout at the Bureau of Supernatural Affairs, she's certain the secretive organization holds the key to locating Quinton--if only she can wrap her head around the idea of magicians, fairies, aliens, and other supernatural creatures all being real. Now she must compete for a spot against kids who've known about magic their whole lives. No matter how hard she tries, Amari can't seem to escape their intense doubt and scrutiny--especially once her supernaturally enhanced talent is deemed "illegal." With an evil magician threatening the supernatural world, and her own classmates thinking she's an enemy, Amari has never felt more alone. But if she doesn't stick it out and pass the tryouts, she may never find out what happened to Quinton
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site.No purchase convenience link provided for 'Avoid' books
This is one of the more pleasantly detailed and lengthy reviews we have seen from Plugged In. Certainly worth a read. We also like the inclusion of Discussion Questions.
Even with all of the detail, we still feel the frequency and weight of all of the magical/supernatural content is very much underplayed here. We also find that the section-based format that sites like Plugged In use often cause the reader to miss or underplay the most important items for Christian parents to consider.
Read ReviewOh man. The reviews on this Christian source are often a bit short, but this one is dangerously light (almost non-existent) when it comes to potentially concerning content. Especially disappointing considering this is a Christian resource.
Read ReviewWoah boy. This is such a good example of why Christians need Christian review sources (CSM is a secular site). Notice the almost complete absence of the content that is potentially concerning from a Christian perspective.
Read ReviewA good example of why Christians need Christian review sources. Notice the absence of the content that is concerning from a Christian perspective.
Read ReviewMy dear brothers and sisters, take note of this: Everyone should be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry, because human anger does not produce the righteousness that God desires. Therefore, get rid of all moral filth and the evil that is so prevalent and humbly accept the word planted in you, which can save you. Do not merely listen to the word, and so deceive yourselves. Do what it says. Anyone who listens to the word but does not do what it says is like someone who looks at his face in a mirror and, after looking at himself, goes away and immediately forgets what he looks like. But whoever looks intently into the perfect law that gives freedom, and continues in it—not forgetting what they have heard, but doing it—they will be blessed in what they do.
— James 1:19-25
More Christian Parent Reviews