Allergic
VERDICT: Recommended
(with caution)
Concern Level: Medium-Low

Concern LevelMedium-Low
Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content
10-year-old Maggie wants a puppy for her birthday and her parents have agreed, but when they go to the pound to pick one, Maggie breaks out in hives, itching and swelling. Allergy testing turns up positive to all animals with fur. When Maggie first finds out about her allergy, she gets very angry, throws a book, has a fit and tears up her room. This is obviously not ok behavior, even for something that to a child it may feel like earth-shattering news. --- She struggles with loneliness because, in her mind, her twin brothers have each other, her parents seem focused on the new baby her mother is expecting) and she is going to a new school where she has no friends. When she does make a new friend (with a new neighbor) this also becomes a source of a set of concerning content. First, Maggie loves going to Claire’s house where she lives with her divorced, artistic, permissive father. At Claire’s house it is quiet and her dad says “Yes!” to everything. When her friend Claire gets a new puppy, Maggie struggles with significant jealousy. Later the friends come up with a scheme to get a mouse (hoping its small size won’t trigger the allergy), but instead of asking Maggie asks for a lock for her door, buys the mouse without permission and then lies when she again develops symptoms. She lies and tells her mom she has a cold and when it seems her allergy meds are not working, Mom takes her to the allergist where she continues to lie. When the truth comes out (her brothers finally tell her parents) Maggie blames her brothers and her friend Claire (Note that she does, in the end, realize she was wrong and apologize).
VerdictRecommended
Our Thoughts
This is the type of book (graphic novel) that could be a good candidate to read together with your child. As you will see above there are quite a few teaching moments that come up. We decided to leave this as Recommended title because the behavior is shown as wrong, Maggie realizes that, is sorry and it is addressed by the parents. It is important as a parent to ensure your child walks away seeing much of Maggie’s behavior as wrong and something she learns from. This can be a really valuable resource if your child has a medical condition or something similar that limits what they are able to do. Another potential teaching moment comes when Maggie says, ”How could something that made me so happy make me sick?” A question often asked in one form or another by our culture (How can something that feels good, makes me happy, etc. be wrong?). Maggie also sees very clearly that being worried that the baby her mother is expecting will take her place in their hearts proves not to be true and when her new sister is born, she finds that the baby loves her and that she loves the baby. Also the family dynamic is solid. She also decides to be a marine biologist (marine animals won’t trigger her allergies). --- Finally, there is also a good reminder/lesson for Christian parents in here. The world is always pushing our kiddos towards desiring endless “freedom”. In this case, this comes up when Maggie asks for a lock on her door, but it can also be open internet access or unmonitored phones or unchecked rooms. Our job from Christ is to realize the times are evil and to guide and protect our kids accordingly… not ensure our kids feel they have a never-ending supply of “freedom”. Another challenge to us comes in the parents dealing with the major issue of dishonesty. Maggie is sorry, but get basically no consequences. This is not a model that will lead to genuine change if adopted over the long-run.
Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution
A coming-of-age middle-grade graphic novel featuring a girl with severe allergies who just wants to find the perfect pet! At home, Maggie is the odd one out. Her parents are preoccupied with getting ready for a new baby, and her younger brothers are twins and always in their own world. Maggie loves animals and thinks a new puppy to call her own is the answer, but when she goes to select one on her birthday, she breaks out in hives and rashes. She's severely allergic to anything with fur! Can Maggie outsmart her allergies and find the perfect pet? With illustrations by Michelle Mee Nutter, Megan Wagner Lloyd uses inspiration from her own experiences with allergies to tell a heartfelt story of family, friendship, and finding a place to belong.
Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link
Interesting review to read through.
Read ReviewAnother interesting review to read through.
Read ReviewThese commandments that I give you today are to be on your hearts. Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates.
— Deuteronomy 6:6-9
More Christian Parent Reviews














