See what's concerning. Find better books.
"I will not set before my eyes anything that is worthless."
Psalm 101:3

Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians

VERDICT: Prayerfully Consider

Concern Level: Medium

Book Cover for Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians

Christian Parent Reviews Cross

Christian Parent Review

Concerning & Potentially Concerning Content

The primary concern from this book comes from attempts at humor that go too far. Examples: “If he starts to sing I may strangle myself” and “of course if you do that I’ll probably have to hunt you down and kill you or dress you in a tunic… I’m still not sure which is worse”. When discussing ‘humility’ he comments that “I sincerely hope you never have to feel this emotion. Like asparagus and fish, it’s not really as good for you as everyone says it is”. Refers to things that are meaningful, important, thoughtful as “you know, boring”. When providing a list of ‘cherished things’ the narrator includes “the bullet that killed your arch nemesis”. A lady is described as business-like, curt and more than a little condescending to which we are told are all good reasons why she wasn’t married. After describing someone different the narrator says, “besides, you’ve seen the type of people who walk around downtown, haven’t you?” There are also immoral comments or actions that are attributed to even the ‘good’ characters. The narrator calls themselves not a good person (a few times), a selfish contemptible fool and a coward. A fire breaks out and Alcatraz doesn’t handle it as an emergency (meant to create a funny scene for the reader). The comment is made that, “This was an absolute lie, but would you have answered any different?” Continuing a statement we listed above he says, “selfishness, arrogance, callousness got me much further than humility ever did. Did I mention I wasn’t a very good person?” Alcatraz gives his foster family “reasonable lies''. In addition to these concerns around humor, there are a few comments that are dark or violent in nature, even though the mood of the book attempts to lighten it considerably. To help understand what we mean by this we will offer an example. Early in the book the main character finds themselves “tied to an altar made of outdated encyclopedias, about to get sacrificed to the dark powers by a cult of evil librarians”. Bad guy tells Alcatraz that he is worthless, fatherless, a parasite on the system. A description of someone crying out in so much pain they’d have killed themselves to stop it. After being captured he said the evil librarians are “about to split me open and spill my blood into the void to complete some dark ritual”. As mentioned above, the evil librarians are referred to as a “cult”. There are a few other random things mentioned: romance novels, Rambo, devilishly handsome, tortured, “tethered to the spirit of my dead ancestors” “gym class for the murderously insane”, “this is suicide”, “staying up until unholy hours of the night” are used. The terms moron, fat, loon, lunatic, maniac, idiot appear as well.

Our Thoughts

This is one of those books that shows the importance of our approach to take detailed notes as we read. This book has a really ‘good’ and kind ending and at the end it is easy to be surprised at the list above because it doesn’t “feel” immoral or dark.. It feels light and funny nearly the whole way through. And yet… all the comments we list above. At its core this feels like a “good” book that is very funny, but there is no question the author is willing to reach too far at times from a moral perspective to achieve this never-ending stream of laughs. This may be one you will need to read through yourself if you are on the fence about your child’s maturity to not be affected by the content above. Or maybe you just skip it, turning instead to options where the author brings humor without crossing the line. For more mature children this is a tricky one you will need to Prayerfully Consider

Plot SummaryNote: This information is typically from the publisher.Use with caution

Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians is the first adventure in a fantasy series for young readers by the #1 New York Times bestselling author Brandon Sanderson. On his thirteenth birthday, foster child Alcatraz Smedry gets a bag of sand in the mail-his only inheritance from his father and mother. He soon learns that this is no ordinary bag of sand. It is quickly stolen by the cult of evil Librarians who are taking over the world by spreading misinformation and suppressing truth. Alcatraz must stop them, using the only weapon he has: an incredible talent for breaking things.

Purchase LinkAbove Reproach: We intentionally do NOT use referral links on this site. Purchase Book Convenience Link

Other Reviews for this Book

Secular Review (use with Caution!)
Compass Book Ratings
Warnings

This secular review is interesting, but, misses on the main moral concerns, which is of course primary for Christians. This is the issue with nearly every book review we read today.

Read Review

Scripture Reflection

Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it. Keep your mouth free of perversity; keep corrupt talk far from your lips. Let your eyes look straight ahead; fix your gaze directly before you. Give careful thought to the paths for your feet and be steadfast in all your ways. Do not turn to the right or the left; keep your foot from evil.

— Proverbs 4:23-27

--- See More Christian Parent Reviews ---

More Christian Parent Reviews